A tool box keeps hand tools and fasteners in one carry-ready place. Plastic boxes are light, metal boxes add drawers and bulk, and stackable systems let you build up a set. Size and trays tell you more than the marketing words do.
The six boxes below run from a 16 inch carry box to a 28 inch foam box and a metal box with three drawers. Dimensions, materials and features come from each product’s listing page. We have not used these boxes ourselves. Several listings show weight limits that look wrong, and we say so below.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links, and they do not change the product information we give.
What to Look For
| Feature | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Size | Match the length to your longest hand tool |
| Material | Plastic is light, steel is heavier and holds drawers |
| Trays and organizers | Lift-out trays keep small parts easy to reach |
| Latches | Metal latches and padlock eyes suit frequent carrying |
| Weight limit | Only trust a figure that fits the box |
Specs at a Glance
| Box | Size and material | Layout | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| DEWALT TSTAK | 17.3 x 11.9 x 13 in; blend | One compartment; removable tray | Stackable; 44 lb listed limit; water resistant per maker |
| CRAFTSMAN 16 in | 15.8 x 8.2 x 7.1 in; metal and plastic | One compartment; portable tray | Padlock eye; metal front latch |
| Plano Grab-N-Go | 16 x 7.5 x 9.5 in; plastic | Lift-out tray; two removable organizers | Low profile; heavy-duty latches |
| STANLEY 16 in | 16 in class; plastic | Two compartments; lid for small parts | One-hand latch; listed dimensions unreliable |
| BIG RED 20.5 in | 20.5 x 8.5 x 12 in; steel | Top box plus 3 drawers | Ball bearing slides; 15.3 lb; 90 lb listed limit |
| STANLEY 28 in | 28 x 12.8 x 11.6 in; structural foam | One compartment; half tray | V-groove with ruler; 10.1 lb |
The 6 Best Tool Boxes
1. DEWALT TSTAK Extra Large Tool Box
A 17.3 by 11.9 by 13 inch box with a 22.71 liter capacity, a removable tray and a bi-material handle. Side latches connect it to other TSTAK units, and the maker calls it water and debris resistant.
Suits: a growing stackable set. Strengths: stacking latches and a deep body. Weaknesses: one main compartment. Skip it if you want drawers.
View DEWALT TSTAK Extra Large Tool Box DWST17806 on Amazon
2. CRAFTSMAN 16 in Lockable Tool Box
A 15.8 by 8.2 by 7.1 inch box in metal and plastic with a padlock eye, a metal front latch, a comfort grip handle and a tray for hand tools. The listing does not call it water resistant, and its 3 pound weight limit looks like an error.
Suits: a small carry box. Strengths: padlock eye and metal latch. Weaknesses: an unclear weight limit. Skip it if you need to know how much it holds.
View CRAFTSMAN 16 in Lockable Tool Box CMST16901 on Amazon
3. Plano Grab-N-Go 16 in Tool Box
A low-profile plastic box measuring 16 by 7.5 by 9.5 inches with a lift-out tray, two removable organizers and heavy-duty latches. The page lists a 5 kg limit, which we cannot check.
Suits: small parts and hand tools. Strengths: two removable organizers. Weaknesses: plastic only. Skip it if you want metal.
View Plano Grab-N-Go 16 in Tool Box with Tray 452-006 on Amazon
4. STANLEY 16 in Tool Box
A plastic box with two compartments, small parts storage in the lid and a one-hand latch that the maker says closes automatically. The listed size (15.5 by 0.22 by 0.16 inches) and 1.1 pound limit cannot be right.
Suits: everyday hand tools. Strengths: a one-hand latch and a lid organizer. Weaknesses: unusable dimensions on the page. Skip it if you need exact sizes.
View STANLEY 16 in Tool Box STST16410 on Amazon
5. BIG RED 20.5 in Metal Tool Box with 3 Drawers
A steel box measuring 20.5 by 8.5 by 12 inches with a top box and three drawers on ball bearing slides, two steel latches, a powder-coat finish and a 1-year warranty. It weighs 15.3 pounds empty and lists a 90 pound limit.
Suits: sorted tools in drawers. Strengths: drawers and steel build. Weaknesses: heavy to carry. Skip it if you want a light box.
View BIG RED 20.5 in Metal Tool Box with 3 Drawers on Amazon
6. STANLEY 28 in Structural Foam Toolbox
A 28 by 12.8 by 11.6 inch box weighing 10.1 pounds, with a V-groove ruler, a half tray for small items and a water resistant build per the maker. The listed 10 pound limit looks like an error.
Suits: long tools. Strengths: length and a built-in ruler. Weaknesses: an unclear weight limit. Skip it if you carry short tools only.
View STANLEY 28 in Structural Foam Portable Toolbox 028001L on Amazon
Care and Setup
- Sort tools by use and keep small parts in the tray.
- Wipe metal and plastic with a dry or barely damp cloth.
- Dry any wet tools before they go in.
- Keep the box off damp floors.
Mistakes to Avoid
- Trusting a weight limit that makes no sense.
- Choosing a box shorter than your longest tool.
- Overfilling the tray until the lid will not close.
- Buying a heavy metal box for light carrying.
Tool Box FAQ
Plastic or metal?
Plastic is lighter. Metal adds drawers and bulk.
Can I stack them?
Only the DEWALT TSTAK is listed as stackable here.
The Short Version
For a stackable set, the DEWALT TSTAK. For a lockable small box, the CRAFTSMAN. For removable organizers, the Plano. For a one-hand latch, the STANLEY 16 inch. For drawers, the BIG RED. For long tools, the STANLEY 28 inch.
