An ice cube tray is one of the simplest tools in a kitchen, but the details vary a lot. Some trays make small cubes for cocktails, others make big square cubes for slow melting, and some come with lids that keep ice away from freezer odors. Cube count, cube size and how you release the ice are the main differences.
The six trays below are all silicone sets, ranging from a three-tray pack to a single tray with a spill-resistant lid. Sizes, counts and features come from each product’s listing page, and claims about materials are the makers’ own. We have not used these trays ourselves.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Links below are affiliate links, and they do not change the product information we give.
What to Look For
| Feature | Why it matters |
|---|---|
| Cubes per tray | More cavities mean fewer refills for a party or a pitcher |
| Cube size | Small cubes fit narrow glasses; large cubes melt more slowly |
| Lid | A lid helps keep freezer odors out and can limit sloshing while you carry a full tray |
| Stacking | Stackable trays make better use of a crowded freezer |
| Release method | Flexible bottoms let you push out single cubes |
Specs at a Glance
| Tray | Cubes | Size details | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|
| TimDonki 3 Pack | 3 trays x 15 = 45 | 7.09 x 5.39 x 2.24 in (listed) | Removable silicone lids; stackable and nesting |
| ChefAide 4 Pack | 4 trays x 14 = 56 | Weight listed as 0.34 kg | Silicone with PP parts; lids; dishwasher safe per maker |
| Tvmania Set of 2 | 2 trays x 15 = 30 | 7.3 x 5.1 x 1.2 in; cubes 1.5 x 1.2 x 0.7 in | Removable lids; maker lists -40 to 428 F range |
| Tovolo Perfect Cube | 2 trays x 15 = 30 | 1.25 in cubes | No lid mentioned in the part we read |
| OXO No-Spill | 14 cubes | 0.75 oz cubes; 0.26 kg | Lid and handle; rounded cubes |
| OXO Small With Lid | 2 trays, 48 cubes | 7/8 in cubes; 12 oz | Supporting base and cover; dishwasher safe |
The 6 Best Ice Cube Trays
1. TimDonki Ice Cube Tray With Lid, 3 Pack
Three silicone trays that make 15 cubes each for 45 in total. The listing describes push-up release, detachable silicone lids and a top frame that lets the trays stack or nest. The lid is meant to sit partly open so it does not crack as liquid expands.
Suits: households that want a lot of ice at once. Strengths: three trays, stackable and nesting. Weaknesses: the lid is not fully sealed by design. Skip it if you want a fully closed lid.
2. ChefAide 4 Pack Ice Cube Tray With Lid
A four-tray set where each tray makes 14 cubes, up to 56 when all are used. The maker describes silicone with food-grade PP parts, a fill line, stackable lids and dishwasher-safe cleaning.
Suits: big batches and entertaining. Strengths: the largest cube count here. Weaknesses: the listing gives few dimensions. Skip it if you need cube measurements first.
View 4 Pack Ice Cube Tray, Silicone Ice Cube Trays for Freezer with Lid on Amazon
3. Tvmania Ice Cube Trays Set of 2, 15-Cube
Two silicone trays with removable lids, 15 cubes each. The listing gives the tray size as 7.3 by 5.1 by 1.2 inches and each cube as about 1.5 by 1.2 by 0.7 inches, with a twist-and-push release.
Suits: a smaller household. Strengths: clear measurements. Weaknesses: only 30 cubes per set. Skip it if you often fill a pitcher.
View Ice Cube Trays Set of 2, 15-Cube Silicone Molds with Removable Lids on Amazon
4. Tovolo Perfect Cube Silicone Ice Trays, Set of 2
Two trays that mold 1.25 inch square cubes, 30 in total. The maker says the larger cubes chill drinks slowly with little dilution, and the flexible silicone lets you remove single cubes.
Suits: whiskey and iced coffee. Strengths: larger cubes. Weaknesses: no lid mentioned in the part we read. Skip it if you want lids for odor control.
View Tovolo Perfect Cube Silicone Ice Trays Set of 2, Charcoal on Amazon
5. OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray
A single tray that makes fourteen 0.75 ounce cubes. The silicone lid is removable, the listing says it seals to help prevent spills and allows angled storage, and there is a handle for filling and carrying.
Suits: carrying a full tray to the freezer. Strengths: handle and lid. Weaknesses: one tray only. Skip it if you want several trays in a set.
View OXO Good Grips No-Spill Ice Cube Tray on Amazon
6. OXO Good Grips Silicone Small Ice Cube Tray With Lid
Two separate trays make 48 small 7/8 inch cubes, sized for cocktails. A base supports the silicone while filling, and the cover helps stacking and keeps ice from absorbing freezer odors, according to the listing.
Suits: small cubes for mixed drinks. Strengths: supporting base, dishwasher safe. Weaknesses: small cubes melt faster. Skip it if you prefer large cubes.
View OXO Good Grips Silicone Small Ice Cube Tray with Lid on Amazon
Care and Use Tips
- Fill to the marked line, or just below the rim, so the tray does not spill.
- Set the tray flat in the freezer before the water starts to freeze.
- Let the tray sit a couple of minutes out of the freezer before releasing cubes.
- Wash new trays before first use and check the maker’s cleaning notes.
Mistakes to Avoid
- Fully sealing a lid on a tray the maker says should stay partly open.
- Carrying an overfull tray with no lid.
- Stacking trays before the top one is level.
- Forgetting that small cubes melt faster than large ones.
Ice Cube Tray FAQ
Are lids necessary?
Not required, but lids are meant to keep freezer odors away from the ice and help stacking. Check the listing for how each lid fits.
Which size suits drinks?
Larger cubes around 1.25 inches suit short glasses and slow melting. Smaller cubes suit tall glasses and cocktails.
The Short Version
For the most ice, the ChefAide 4 pack or the TimDonki 3 pack. For clear measurements, the Tvmania. For larger cubes, the Tovolo. For a spill-resistant single tray, the OXO No-Spill. For small cocktail cubes, the OXO small tray with lid.
