Skip to content
RESEARCH-BASED GUIDES. PRACTICAL EVERYDAY ADVICE.How we pick products
TKTop Rated KitchenwareA more thoughtful kitchen
Microwaves

Best Microwaves 2017consumer Reports

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. How we pick products

Where to buy

Check the latest price, availability and delivery on Amazon. Orders are placed on Amazon. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

See 4 more Amazon options
Read the full guide ↓

Disclosure: topratedkitchenware.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission from Amazon and other retailers, at no extra cost to you.

Where to buy

The six models below are the verified picks for this guide, chosen by applying the classic test-report criteria to today’s countertop market. Each name links to its Amazon listing, where you can check the latest price on Amazon, confirm the current specifications, and read the newest owner feedback before you decide.

Read the full guide ↓ for what the 2017-era test reports actually measured, why their specific rankings should not be followed literally today, and how their criteria — applied to current models — produce the shortlist above.

People searching for the best microwaves 2017consumer reports covered are usually doing something sensible: looking for independent, laboratory-style testing instead of marketing. The instinct is right and the date is the problem. A test report from 2017 evaluated the models on sale in 2017, several of which have since been revised, renamed, or discontinued, and none of which can be bought new with any confidence that the tested unit matches a current production run. This guide takes the useful half of that search seriously. It explains what the classic consumer-test methodology of that era measured — heating evenness, defrosting quality, cooking speed, ease of use, and noise — shows you how to run the same judgements on today’s models, and then applies those criteria to six verified current countertop microwaves. One thing it will not do is invent scores: we do not reproduce or fabricate any publication’s ratings, for 2017 models or for these.

Why do the old criteria still deserve respect? Because microwave cooking physics has not changed. A test kitchen in 2017 that heated a ring of food and mapped its hot and cold spots was measuring the same uneven energy field your dinner meets tonight. Defrosting tests that weighed cooked edges against frozen centres describe exactly the weakness inverter models were built to fix. Usability scoring — can a first-time user reheat a plate without the manual — remains the fastest predictor of whether a household will be happy. What dates is not the method but the model list, and the reliability picture: a design that was new in 2017 now has years of owner history behind it, which is information no launch-era report could contain. Readers who enjoy test-kitchen methodology generally may also appreciate the approach taken in Best Microwaves Americas Test Kitchen style coverage, while readers whose real question is a current size or wattage class should pair this guide with Best Microwaves 900w for the compact end of today’s market.

Inside: the six current picks judged by the classic criteria, a comparison table, a section translating each 2017 test into a check you can perform or verify today, a how-to section for testing your own new microwave in its first week, and a clear account of what to do when an old report’s winner cannot be bought anymore.

Key Takeaways

  • Use 2017-era reports for their method, not their model list: the tests remain valid, the specific winners have been revised or discontinued.
  • The classic criteria — heating evenness, defrosting, speed, usability, noise — are still the right questions to ask of any current microwave.
  • Never trust a site that quotes a publication’s scores for models it cannot have tested; verify methodology claims and buy on criteria you can check.
  • Today’s descendants of 2017’s favoured designs add inverter delivery, sensors, and flatbed cavities that the older tests would have rewarded.
  • Run the classic tests yourself in the first week: a water-heating check, an evenness check with a ring of food, and a defrost check tell you more than any badge.
  • The six picks here are current, verified models ranked by those criteria — led by the inverter flatbed that answers the era’s two biggest criticisms at once.
In this guide

Quick Picks

  • Best Overall — TOSHIBA Flatbed Microwave Oven with Inverter Technology, 1.3 Cu.Ft, 1200W. The modern answer to the classic tests: even inverter defrosting, no turntable limits, sensor reheating. Check on Amazon
  • Best by the Classic Criteria — TOSHIBA Countertop Microwave Oven, 1.2 Cu.Ft, 1000W, Black. Sensor cooking, 12 menus, and a full-size turntable: the traditional format perfected. Check on Amazon
  • Best Usability Score — Farberware Countertop Microwave Oven 1.1 cu.ft, 1000 Watts, Stainless Steel. Multi-stage cooking and defrost by weight or time, the control depth test kitchens reward. Check on Amazon
  • Best Simple Classic — BLACK+DECKER Microwave Oven Countertop, 1.1 Cu.Ft, 1000W, Stainless Steel. Push-button door and six presets: the era’s favourite format in its plainest modern form. Check on Amazon
  • Best Compact — Chefman Countertop Microwave Oven 0.9 Cu. Ft., 900 Watts, Black. Ten power levels, mute, and ECO mode in the size class the old reports covered for small kitchens. Check on Amazon
  • Best Budget — COMFEE’ Countertop Microwave Oven, 0.7 Cu.Ft, 700W, Black. The dorm-and-office class judged by the same criteria: simple, quiet-able, and honest about its limits. Check on Amazon

How These Picks Were Chosen

The method deliberately imitates the structure of the classic reports while using only verifiable current data. Every model was confirmed against its manufacturer’s listing through the Creators API — capacity, wattage, and features in the spec boxes come from that verification and nowhere else. We then scored the verified field against the five classic criteria, using design evidence rather than invented lab numbers: evenness judged by cavity system and power delivery (inverter and flatbed designs address the known physics), defrosting by power-delivery type and defrost programming, speed by rated output, usability by control layout and feature completeness, and ownership noise by the presence of mute functions and ECO standby. We performed no laboratory testing and we reproduce no publication’s scores; where the guide describes what the 2017-era tests measured, it describes methodology that is a matter of public record, not results attributed to any specific model.

The ranking that emerged will look familiar to anyone who read those reports: the top of the list is occupied by the models that fix the era’s documented complaints. The inverter flatbed leads because it answers the evenness and defrosting criticisms simultaneously. The sensor Toshiba follows as the classic format with its reheating weakness engineered out. The Farberware’s programming depth earns the usability badge the old testers valued. The compact picks are judged by the same criteria at their scale rather than excused from them. Readers who started from a specific old winner should read the section below on discontinued models before mourning it — in most cases its modern descendant, sometimes in this very list, is the better buy.

The 6 Best Microwaves by the Classic Test Criteria

TOSHIBA 1.2 Cu Ft Countertop Microwave — best microwaves 2017consumer reports

TOSHIBA Countertop Microwave Oven, 1.2 Cu.Ft, 1000W, Black

Badge: Best by the Classic Criteria

Strengths

  • Humidity-sensor reheating directly answers the evenness-and-quality test the classic reports weighted heavily.
  • 12.4-inch turntable and 1.2 cu ft cavity match the family format the 2017-era favourites occupied.
  • 12 auto menus, mute, and ECO mode give it the usability completeness testers scored.

Trade-offs

  • Conventional pulsed low power; its defrosting would not top the classic defrost test against inverter rivals.
  • 1000W is mid-class speed — brisk, not class-leading.
  • Sensor quality rewards users who actually select the sensor programs.

Spec box: Capacity 1.2 cu ft · Power 1000W · Finish: black · 12.4-inch removable turntable · Smart humidity sensor · 12 auto menus · Mute function · ECO mode · Easy Clean interior

Judged the way a 2017 test kitchen judged, this Toshiba is the traditional format with its homework done. The classic reheating test — a standard portion, heated once, assessed for hot spots and dried edges — is precisely the task its humidity sensor automates, reading the food’s moisture and ending the cycle at readiness instead of at a timer’s guess. The format around the sensor is the era’s family standard: 1.2 cu ft, a turntable that takes a dinner plate flat, 1000W of honest mid-class power. Add the usability details testers logged — a mute for quiet homes, an ECO mode for standby, an interior designed to wipe clean — and you have the pick that would have sat comfortably near the top of the old tables, with the sensor as its modern signature.

Its defrosting is where the era’s other big test separates it from the leader below: pulsed power asks for turning and patience, and the classic defrost test punished exactly that. Households whose week is defrost-heavy should take the inverter flatbed; reheat-heavy households will find this the criteria’s sweet spot.

Best for: families who want the classic format judged best on reheating quality / Not suited for: heavy defrosters, who need inverter delivery

TOSHIBA Countertop Microwave Oven
TOSHIBA Countertop Microwave Oven

Check on Amazon

COMFEE 0.7 Cu Ft Countertop Microwave — best microwaves 2017consumer reports

COMFEE’ Countertop Microwave Oven, 0.7 Cu.Ft, 700W, Black

Badge: Best Budget

Strengths

  • Usability the old testers prized in compacts: one-touch controls a first-time user cannot get wrong.
  • Sound on/off answers the noise criterion that compact roundups of the era already tracked.
  • ECO mode addresses standby draw, a running-cost line in classic test tables.

Trade-offs

  • 700W would score at the slow end of any era’s speed test; frozen meals need generous added time.
  • 0.7 cu ft fails the family-capacity question outright — by design.
  • No sensor or inverter to lift its evenness and defrost marks.

Spec box: Capacity 0.7 cu ft · Power 700W · Finish: black · ECO mode · Sound on/off · One-touch buttons · Child safety lock

The classic reports always included the compact class, and they judged it by a fair rule: a small microwave should be excellent at small jobs rather than apologetic at large ones. By that rule the COMFEE’ is a respectable modern compact. Its one-touch panel is the usability ideal the testers described — press the beverage button, get a hot beverage — its sound control respects the dorm and office settings it will live in, and its ECO mode trims the standby cost that test tables itemised. Its scores on the cooking criteria are what its class dictates: slow by the stopwatch, small by the tape, and entirely adequate for the mugs, bowls, and single servings it exists to heat.

Buy it as the reports would have advised: for one person, one portion, in a small space — the use case the apartment-focused research in Best Microwaves Apartment also centres. Ask it to do family duty and you are repeating the mismatch the classic capacity tests were designed to catch.

Best for: dorms, offices, and single-person kitchens judged on compact criteria / Not suited for: family cooking or frozen-meal duty

COMFEE' Countertop Microwave Oven
COMFEE' Countertop Microwave Oven

Check on Amazon

Farberware 1.1 Cu Ft Countertop Microwave — best microwaves 2017consumer reports

Farberware Countertop Microwave Oven 1.1 cu.ft, 1000 Watts, Stainless Steel

Badge: Best Usability Score

Strengths

  • Multi-stage cooking is the control depth classic usability tests rewarded and most rivals still omit.
  • Defrost by weight or time covers both the labelled pack and the home-frozen container in the defrost test’s spirit.
  • Express cooking plus a clear LED display keep first-use success high.

Trade-offs

  • No sensor, so the reheating test rests on presets and user judgement.
  • Conventional pulsed low power in defrosting.
  • The programming depth is wasted on users who only ever press express cook.

Spec box: Capacity 1.1 cu ft · Power 1000W · Finish: stainless steel · 10 power levels · Multi-stage cooking · 6 preset options · Defrost by weight or time · LED display · Express cooking

Classic test reports reserved some of their warmest language for controls that let a cook actually cook, and the Farberware is this list’s keeper of that tradition. Multi-stage programming — defrost, rest, cook, in one sequence — is the feature that turns a microwave from a reheating box into a cooking appliance, and the dual defrost methods show the same thoughtfulness: weight for the supermarket pack with a label, time for the container from your own freezer without one. In the 1.1 cu ft, 1000W format that defined the era’s family mainstream, it is the pick a test kitchen would have lingered over.

Its reheating, lacking a sensor, depends on the presets and the cook — the honest gap between it and the Toshiba above. Buyers who program will close that gap with skill; buyers who will not should buy the sensor instead. The criteria do not change; the user does.

Best for: cooks who use staged programs and both defrost methods / Not suited for: users who want sensor automation

Check on Amazon

Chefman 0.9 Cu Ft Microwave 900 Watts — best microwaves 2017consumer reports

Chefman Countertop Microwave Oven 0.9 Cu. Ft., 900 Watts, Black

Badge: Best Compact

Strengths

  • Full 10 power levels at compact size — the control completeness classic tests scored and compacts usually skip.
  • Mute and ECO mode cover the noise and running-cost criteria in a small cabinet.
  • 900W gives it a genuine speed edge over 700W compacts in any era’s timing test.

Trade-offs

  • 0.9 cu ft still limits the largest plates and family dishes.
  • No sensor or inverter to lift its evenness marks.
  • Six presets is the standard set, not the Toshiba’s twelve.

Spec box: Capacity 0.9 cu ft · Power 900W · Finish: black · 10 power levels · 6 cooking presets · One-touch express cook · Eco mode · Child safety lock · Mute button

Between the dorm compact and the family mainstream sits the size the classic reports treated as the small-kitchen answer, and the Chefman is its strongest modern representative here. The detail a test kitchen would circle is the full set of ten power levels: compact models usually simplify their controls, but this one keeps the complete range, which means its defrosting, melting, and gentle reheating can be done by the book rather than by approximation. Add express cook for the daily routine, a mute for thin walls, ECO standby, and a child lock, and the usability column fills in completely. At 900W its speed sits honestly between the classes — slower than the family models, brisker than the 700W compact — exactly where its size says it should.

For one or two people in a small kitchen, this is the criteria applied at the right scale. For a family’s main oven, the capacity ceiling is the disqualifier the old capacity tests existed to state.

Best for: one- and two-person kitchens wanting full controls in a compact / Not suited for: family-size dishes or the largest plates

Check on Amazon

BLACK+DECKER 1.1 Cu Ft Microwave 1000W — best microwaves 2017consumer reports

BLACK+DECKER Microwave Oven Countertop, 1.1 Cu.Ft, 1000W, Stainless Steel

Badge: Best Simple Classic

Strengths

  • The era’s canonical format — 1.1 cu ft, 1000W, six presets — executed without clutter.
  • Push-button door scores on the usability and durability judgements alike.
  • Child safety lock completes the family basics the classic reports checked for.

Trade-offs

  • No sensor, no staging, no inverter: the criteria’s technology columns stay empty.
  • Reheating quality is the user’s skill, as it was in 2017.
  • Stainless finish shows fingerprints.

Spec box: Capacity 1.1 cu ft · Power 1000W · Finish: stainless steel · Push-button door · Child safety lock · 6 auto cook presets · 10 power levels

If a 2017 test report were reprinted with one current model swapped in unnoticed, this BLACK+DECKER would be the swap nobody spotted. It is the period’s mainstream specification in modern dress: mid-size cavity, 1000W, ten power levels, six auto presets, a child lock, and a door — push-button here, a small modern kindness to the latch — that opens the way doors always have. Judged by the classic criteria it is the control group: competent everywhere, exceptional nowhere, and honest about both. The reports valued that profile for buyers who wanted the standard appliance without a learning curve, and the intervening years of owner experience with this format have only confirmed the judgement.

Choose it when the household’s cooking is the standard repertoire and simplicity is the feature. Choose upward — sensor, staging, or inverter — when your week includes the jobs those technologies transform. The criteria make the decision; this model makes it easy to accept.

Best for: buyers who want the classic mainstream format with zero learning curve / Not suited for: cooks who want modern automation

Check on Amazon

TOSHIBA Flatbed Inverter Microwave 1200W — best microwaves 2017consumer reports

TOSHIBA Flatbed Microwave Oven with Inverter Technology, 1.3 Cu.Ft, 1200W, Black Stainless Steel

Badge: Best Overall

Strengths

  • Inverter delivery is the direct answer to the classic defrost test’s central complaint about pulsed power.
  • Flatbed cavity removes the turntable constraint that the evenness tests worked around.
  • Smart sensor plus 1200W pace leads the list on reheating quality and speed together.

Trade-offs

  • Its technology postdates the 2017 tables — it is their beneficiary, not their subject.
  • Premium tier over the classic-format models.
  • A substantial footprint that small kitchens must measure for.

Spec box: Capacity 1.3 cu ft · Power 1200W · Finish: black stainless steel · Inverter technology · Smart sensor · Mute function · No turntable (flatbed)

Every era’s test reports end with a wish list, and the late-2010s lists were consistent: defrosting that did not cook the edges, cavities that took real dishes, reheating that did not need a timer’s guess. This Toshiba is what the wish list looks like answered. The inverter supplies continuous low power, so the defrost test’s cooked-rim problem is engineered away rather than managed. The flatbed deletes the turntable, so rectangular dishes use the whole cavity and the evenness question changes from how well the plate rotates to how well the field is stirred — Toshiba’s answer being well enough to anchor this guide. The smart sensor retires reheating guesswork, and 1200W makes it the fastest model here into the bargain.

It is, deliberately, the guide’s anachronism: a machine the 2017 reports could not have tested, ranked first by their criteria. That is the correct relationship between old methods and new models, and buyers fitting it into period-sized kitchens should check the placement guidance gathered under Best Microwaves 21 Inch Width.

Best for: buyers who want the classic criteria answered by current technology / Not suited for: strict budgets or the smallest counters

Check on Amazon

Comparison Table

Pick Badge Capacity Power Strongest classic criterion Link
TOSHIBA 1.2 Cu.Ft Black Best by the Classic Criteria 1.2 cu ft 1000W Reheating quality (sensor) Check on Amazon
COMFEE’ 0.7 Cu.Ft Best Budget 0.7 cu ft 700W Compact usability and quiet Check on Amazon
Farberware 1.1 cu.ft Best Usability Score 1.1 cu ft 1000W Control depth (multi-stage) Check on Amazon
Chefman 0.9 Cu. Ft. Best Compact 0.9 cu ft 900W Compact control completeness Check on Amazon
BLACK+DECKER 1.1 Cu.Ft Best Simple Classic 1.1 cu ft 1000W Mainstream simplicity Check on Amazon
TOSHIBA Flatbed 1.3 Cu.Ft Best Overall 1.3 cu ft 1200W Defrosting and evenness (inverter, flatbed) Check on Amazon

Best Microwaves 2017consumer Reports Style: What the Tests Measured and How to Check It Today

The classic methodology rested on a handful of repeatable tests, and each has a home equivalent or a specification you can verify. The evenness test heated a standard load and compared temperatures across it; your home version is a ring of marshmallows or a plate of grated cheese heated briefly — browning and melting patterns reveal the hot spots — or, more practically, a casserole reheated and checked at centre and edges. The defrost test thawed a standard block of frozen mince and judged the spread between cooked edges and frozen centre; yours is the same block from your own freezer, defrosted by the program and pulled apart by hand. The speed test timed water heating; yours is the two-minute mug test from our other guides. The usability test handed the oven to a new user; yours is watching a family member reheat lunch without asking you anything. The noise test measured the fan and the beeps; yours is standing in the next room during a cycle and deciding whether the mute button matters to your household.

Two of the era’s lines deserve special translation. Reliability predictions in a 2017 report were projections from brand history; today, the same brands carry actual owner history for these model families, and recent owner feedback on a listing is the modern, messier, but real version of that line. And the value judgement — performance for the tier — survives intact: the classic reports were famously willing to rank a well-judged mid-tier model above a feature-stacked flagship, a discipline this guide has followed in placing the sensor Toshiba and the Farberware where it has. When you read any roundup, old or new, that willingness is the tell of a criteria-led guide. The garbled search variants that float around this topic — Best Microwaves 2107 among them — all lead back to the same need: independent criteria, honestly applied, to models you can actually buy.

How to Test Your New Microwave in Its First Week

Run the classic suite, home edition, while the return window is open. Day one: the water test — a mug, two minutes, steaming hot — plus a check that the turntable runs true or the flatbed heats across its floor with a small dish in each corner in turn. Day two: the evenness check — reheat a familiar casserole and test centre and edges; note the stirring habit your cavity asks for. Day three: the defrost check — a standard portion of mince on the defrost program, separated at the pauses, judged by how little of it cooked. Day four: the usability check — hand the panel to the household’s least technical member with no coaching. Day five: the noise check, at night, from the next room. Any machine in this guide should pass that week without drama; a machine that fails it has told you something no specification sheet would, at the one moment when acting on it is free.

Troubleshooting during the test week follows the usual patterns. Problem: the evenness check shows a persistent cold centre → arrange food in a ring or a shallower layer and add standing time before concluding the cavity is at fault; geometry explains most cold centres. Problem: defrosting cooks the edges → the pieces went in as one block, or the weight entry was optimistic; separate earlier and enter the true weight. Problem: the new oven seems slower than its rating suggests → verify with the water test against your old machine rather than by feel, because new-cavity impressions deceive, especially moving between sizes.

When the Old Winner Cannot Be Bought Anymore

The most common outcome of following a 2017 shortlist literally is a discontinued model, a marketplace listing at a collector’s premium, or a revised unit wearing the old name with different internals. None of those is a purchase to make. The correct move is genealogical: identify what the old winner was — its size class, its wattage, the feature that earned its ranking — and buy its modern descendant by criteria. Sensor-led family models of that era descend to the sensor Toshiba in this guide. The era’s mainstream stainless format descends to the BLACK+DECKER and the Farberware. Its premium technology hopes descend, frankly, to the inverter flatbed that now leads the list. Chasing the literal old model buys you an ageing appliance with an unknown history; buying its descendant by the same criteria buys you the ranking’s actual intent, with a full warranty and current parts support. That translation, more than any individual pick, is the service a dated report needs — and the one this guide exists to provide, for searchers arriving from every variant of the query, including the capacity-led detour through Best Microwaves 9 Cu Ft.

Reliability, Years Later: What Owner History Adds to an Old Report

A launch-era report can measure everything except time. It cannot know which keypad fades, which door latch loosens in year three, or which model’s fan grows loud with age — yet those are the facts that decide whether a microwave was a good purchase. The years since 2017 have supplied that missing chapter for the model families in this guide, and the modern buyer’s advantage over the 2017 reader is precisely this hindsight. The formats that dominate this list — mainstream turntable models from high-volume brands, and the now-mature inverter lines — are the ones whose long-term behaviour is documented by sheer numbers of owners. When you read current owner feedback for any pick here, read it the way an analyst reads the old reports: look for patterns across many reports rather than single stories, weight complaints about components (latches, keypads, turntable drives) over complaints about couriers, and notice whether the brand’s responses suggest a functioning support operation. A model family with years of unremarkable, satisfied ownership behind it is the closest thing the real world offers to a reliability test — and it is a test no 2017 table could have printed.

This is also where the dated report can mislead in the opposite direction. A brand projected as reliable in 2017 may have changed factories, ownership, or component suppliers since; a brand then considered middling may have quietly improved. Projections expire. The discipline this guide recommends is to let the old report frame the questions, let current specifications answer the measurable ones, and let recent owner history answer the durability one. Three sources, three jobs, no single document trusted beyond its competence — that is the mature version of the consumer-test idea, and it is available to every buyer willing to spend twenty minutes assembling it.

The Kitchen Changed Too: 2017 Assumptions Worth Revisiting

Test reports encode the kitchen of their moment, and some of 2017’s background assumptions deserve a fresh look. Family sizes and working patterns have shifted toward smaller households and more home working, which moves the sensible capacity centre down for many buyers — one reason the 0.9 cu ft Chefman earns a full place in this guide rather than a footnote. Meal-kit and meal-prep habits have made rectangular containers the default leftover vessel, which is the flatbed’s moment arriving a few years after the reports that wished for it. Open-plan living has made noise a first-class criterion rather than a table footnote, which is why mute functions appear in this guide’s key takeaways rather than its fine print. And the home now contains more competing countertop appliances than it did — the air fryer above all — which sharpens the capacity advice: buy the microwave size your actual microwave jobs need, because the counter it shares is more contested than the one the 2017 testers imagined. Criteria endure; contexts move. A guide that updates the second while honouring the first is the honest heir of the reports this search celebrates.

A Short Field Guide to Reading Any Roundup, Old or New

The habits that protect you with a 2017 report protect you with this year’s content too, including this guide. Ask first what was actually examined: a laboratory test, a verified specification set, or a paragraph rewritten from a listing — each has its place, and honest guides say which they are offering, as this one does. Ask second whether the criteria are stated before the ranking; a guide that explains its tests and then ranks is reasoning in public, while a guide that ranks and then justifies is decorating a conclusion. Ask third whether the limitations are printed where you can see them — the honest limitation in each review here, the prose-only treatments in our wattage guides, the discontinued-model warnings in this one. Ask fourth whether numbers that look precise could possibly be known: scores, failure figures, and performance claims should trace to a method or a manufacturer, never to confidence. A roundup that passes those four questions deserves your attention whatever its date; one that fails them deserves your scepticism whatever its branding. The consumer-test tradition, at its best, was never really about the winning model in a given year. It was about teaching buyers to ask those questions for themselves — and that lesson has not dated at all.

Common Buying Mistakes

  • Following a dated ranking literally. Models are revised and discontinued; criteria are not. Buy the method’s current answer, not its historical one.
  • Trusting quoted scores you cannot verify. Any site can print a number beside a famous publication’s name. If the methodology and the model year do not line up, the number is decoration.
  • Assuming a same-named model is the tested model. Manufacturers revise internals under existing names. The unit tested years ago may not be the unit in the box today.
  • Ignoring owner history that postdates the report. Years of real use reveal what launch testing cannot. Recent owner feedback is the modern reliability line.
  • Skipping your own first-week tests. The classic checks take an evening in total and are only free while the return window is open.
  • Judging new technology by old categories. Inverter and flatbed designs answer the old tests in new ways; forcing them into period boxes undersells what changed.

Final Recommendation

Let the classic criteria choose, and they choose the TOSHIBA Flatbed Inverter — the current machine that answers the era’s defrosting, evenness, and capacity criticisms in one design. If you prefer the traditional format those reports knew, the TOSHIBA 1.2 Cu.Ft sensor model is its perfected descendant, and the Farberware 1.1 carries their usability tradition. That is the right way to honour a search for the best microwaves 2017consumer reports once ranked: keep the questions those testers asked, and let today’s verified models answer them.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I still buy the microwaves that 2017 reports recommended?

Sometimes, but rarely as the same product. Popular models are revised under the same name, replaced by successors, or discontinued outright, and remaining stock may be old inventory. The safer route is to identify the size, wattage, and key feature that earned the old recommendation and buy its current equivalent — which is how this guide’s shortlist was built.

Did Consumer Reports test the models in this guide?

This guide makes no such claim, and you should distrust any page that casually does. Several of these models postdate 2017 entirely. What this guide does is apply the classic consumer-test criteria — evenness, defrosting, speed, usability, noise — to current verified models, using manufacturers’ specifications and design evidence, without reproducing or inventing any publication’s scores.

Why do old test reports still rank in search results?

Because the questions they answered are permanent and the pages accumulated authority over years. Treat them as methodology references: their tests explain what to look for, while their model tables describe a market that no longer exists. Pair them with a current, verified shortlist before spending money.

What was the most important test in the classic methodology?

For most households, the defrost and evenness tests, because they measure the two things microwaves do worst and owners feel most. Speed is easy to read from a wattage rating; usability shows itself in a day. Evenness and defrosting are where designs genuinely differ, which is why inverter and sensor models — built to fix them — lead this guide.

How can I tell if a review site is inventing test results?

Look for specifics that can be checked: named test loads, measured times, stated conditions, and model years that match the claims. Vague superlatives, scores without methods, and ratings attributed to publications for models those publications could not have tested are the warning signs. A research-led guide will tell you plainly what it verified and what it did not test — as this one does.

Are today’s microwaves actually better than the 2017 generation?

In the areas the old tests criticised, yes: inverter defrosting, sensor reheating, and flatbed cavities are mainstream now, and they address the period’s documented weaknesses directly. In basic reheating of simple foods, a good 2017 mainstream model and its modern descendant are close — which is exactly why the descendants, with warranties and parts support, are the rational buy.

Should I pay for access to old test reports before buying a microwave?

Reading the methodology is worthwhile; paying primarily for a dated model table is hard to justify for a single appliance purchase. The criteria those reports established are summarised in this guide and across reputable current sources. If you already have access, use the old reports to learn the tests, then verify today’s models against current specifications and owner history before deciding.

Do manufacturers still design microwaves to the old test criteria?

Indirectly, yes. Evenness, defrosting, and usability are the qualities owners notice and return products over, so the market optimises for them whether or not a specific test exists. The inverter, sensor, and flatbed features leading this guide are the industry’s answers to the exact weaknesses the classic tests documented — the clearest evidence that the criteria outlived the reports that popularised them.

What if a current model shares its name with a 2017 favourite?

Treat the shared name as a starting hint, not as evidence. Check the current model’s specifications against the ones the old report praised — capacity, wattage, the signature feature — and read recent owner feedback for the current production version. Manufacturers revise internals under familiar names, so the descendant may be better, worse, or simply different. The criteria transfer; the verdict must be re-earned, which is the entire argument of this guide in one answer.

Are professional test kitchens still useful for microwave shopping?

Yes, for the same reason they were useful in 2017: controlled tests reveal evenness and defrosting behaviour that specifications cannot tell you. Use current test coverage where it exists, prefer reports that describe their loads and methods, and combine their findings with verified specifications and owner history. No single source — laboratory, guide, or crowd — sees the whole appliance; the buyer’s job is to triangulate, and this guide is built to be one honest leg of that triangle.

How often should I replace a microwave, going by test-era expectations?

There is no calendar rule; replace on condition and fit. A mainstream model that still heats evenly, latches positively, and suits your household’s size has not expired because a newer ranking exists. Replace when the cavity coating is damaged, the door or latch feels loose, heating becomes erratic, or your household’s needs have genuinely changed — and let current criteria-led shortlists, not nostalgia for a past winner, choose the successor.

Where can I verify a microwave’s specifications without a test report?

On the manufacturer’s own listing and manual for the exact model number: rated output wattage, capacity, turntable size, and feature set are all stated there, and they are the figures this guide’s spec boxes reproduce from verified listing data. If a roundup’s numbers disagree with the manufacturer’s documents, believe the documents.

What is the single most transferable lesson from the 2017-era reports?

That the best appliance is the one that performs on the criteria your household actually exercises, verified by a method you can inspect. Rankings age, models turn over, and marketing renames the same features every season — but a buyer who knows their own tests, from the defrost block to the first-week water check, can evaluate any microwave in any year. That independence, more than any winning model, is what those reports were really selling.

Do I need a sensor or inverter model to match the old winners?

Not necessarily — the old winners themselves were conventional machines, and the classic-format picks in this guide match their profile closely. Sensor and inverter models lead because they answer the criteria better, not because the criteria demand them. A household whose cooking is simple reheating will be well served by the classic picks; a household heavy on defrosting and delicate work is the one that should pay for the newer answers.

Why does this guide not simply name the 2017 winner?

Because naming it would send you shopping for a discontinued or revised appliance on the strength of tests performed on a production run from years ago — the exact mistake this guide exists to prevent. The winner’s criteria live on in the picks above; its box, by now, belongs in a museum of good intentions.