Skip to content
RESEARCH-BASED GUIDES. PRACTICAL EVERYDAY ADVICE.How we pick products
TKTop Rated KitchenwareA more thoughtful kitchen
Grills

Best Grills For Grilling Smoking

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. How we pick products

Where to buy

Check the latest price, availability and delivery on Amazon. Orders are placed on Amazon. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

See 4 more Amazon options
Read the full guide ↓

Disclosure: topratedkitchenware.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission from Amazon and other retailers, at no extra cost to you.

Where to buy

The six models below are the verified picks for this guide to best grills for grilling & smoking. Each name links to its Amazon listing, where you can check the latest price on Amazon, confirm the current configuration, and read the newest owner feedback before you decide.

Read the full guide ↓ for the ranking logic, the honest limitations of every pick, and the buying checks that matter more than any headline claim.

If you are shopping for the best grills for grilling & smoking, you need one honest fact before any ranking: the six verified picks in this guide are all propane gas grills, and not one of them is a dedicated smoker. That is not a reason to close the page. Gas grills sear, roast, and grill superbly, and with indirect heat plus a smoker box or a pellet tube they can lay down genuine, if lighter, smoke flavour on ribs, chicken, and fish. What they cannot do is hold a thin blue smoke for twelve hours the way an offset smoker or a pellet grill can. This guide is written for the large group of cooks who grill several times a week, smoke occasionally, and want one machine that handles both jobs credibly rather than a specialist that sits idle most of the year.

That framing shapes every badge below. We judged these six grills first on grilling: burner layout, grate material, cooking area, and how honestly each design handles two-zone cooking, because two-zone control is also the foundation of gas-grill smoking. A grill that can hold a calm indirect zone on one side while the other side stays hot is a grill that can smoke a rack of ribs without scorching it. A grill that runs uniformly hot everywhere is a searing machine and nothing more. Readers whose main question is throughput rather than smoke should also look at Best Grills For High Volume, which ranks a closely related shortlist purely on capacity and recovery speed.

You will find no invented smoke performance here. Where a pick helps the smoking side of the brief, we say exactly how: a cabinet that stores a smoker box and wood chips neatly, cast iron grates that hold heat steady during long indirect cooks, or a sear zone that finishes smoked food properly at the end. Where a pick works against smoking, we say that too. The goal is a guide you can trust enough to cook from, not a list that pretends six gas grills are six smokers.

Key Takeaways

  • Every pick in this guide is a propane gas grill. All six grill excellently; all six smoke only in the lighter, indirect sense explained throughout this guide.
  • Two-zone control is the whole game: one side lit, one side off, food on the cool side, smoke source over the lit side.
  • Cast iron and porcelain-enameled cast iron grates hold steadier heat during long indirect cooks than thin steel grates.
  • A smoker box or pellet tube is a small, inexpensive add-on; no pick here includes a built-in smoker chamber.
  • If most of your cooking is low-and-slow barbecue, buy a dedicated smoker instead and treat this guide as a grilling reference.
  • Check the latest price on Amazon for each pick, and confirm burner count and cooking area on the listing before you decide.
In this guide

Quick Picks

Pick Badge Why it earns its place Listing
Nexgrill 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner Best Overall The largest confirmed cooking space in the group, a side burner, and cabinet storage make it the most complete grilling-and-smoking compromise. Check on Amazon
Weber Spirit E-425 Gas Grill Best Premium Porcelain-enameled cast iron grates and a dedicated sear zone make it the strongest finisher of smoked food in the group. Check on Amazon
Electactic 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner Best Mid-Size All-Rounder Four burners, a side burner, stainless construction, and a thermometer cover both halves of the brief without excess size. Check on Amazon
Charbroil Performance Series 4-Burner Cabinet Grill Best for Cabinet Storage A four-burner cabinet design that keeps smoking tools, chips, and gear enclosed and organised. Check on Amazon
IdeaMaxx 3-Burner Gas Grill Most Portable Gas Pick Foldable shelves and cast iron grates make it the easiest pick to move, store, and still smoke on at a campsite or small patio. Check on Amazon
Charbroil Classic 3-Burner Gas Grill Best for Small Patios A compact 360 sq. in. three-burner with porcelain-coated grates that covers everyday grilling and light smoking for small households. Check on Amazon

Shoppers who mostly cook skewers rather than brisket will find the same hardware judged through a different lens in Best Grills For Indian Kebab, where grate spacing and high direct heat matter more than smoke.

How These Picks Were Chosen

This guide is research-led, not a hands-on test report, and it does not pretend otherwise. The six picks come from a verified pool for the grills category: each model was included only where its brand, fuel type, and listing details could be confirmed against its Amazon listing title. We compared the confirmed designs on the factors that decide whether a gas grill can credibly cover a grilling and smoking brief: number of burners and how independently they can be run, total cooking area, grate material and mass, the presence of a side burner for sauces and finishing work, cabinet storage for the tools smoking requires, and ignition type.

The smoking assessment deserves a plain explanation, because it is where guides in this category most often mislead. No manufacturer figure for smoke output exists for gas grills, so we did not invent one. Instead we assessed each design on the physical requirements of indirect smoking: can you light one or two burners and leave the rest off, is the lid substantial enough to hold a pocket of warm smoky air, and is there grate room for a water pan alongside the food? Every pick here passes those basic tests, which is why the guide exists at all. None passes the harder test of being a true smoker, which is why the limitation is stated in the introduction rather than buried.

Badges were assigned after that comparison, and each badge names the job the pick does best within this specific brief. Best Overall went to the grill with the largest confirmed cooking space and the strongest all-round specification, because grilling and smoking both reward room. The premium badge went to the design with a dedicated sear feature, because finishing smoked food over fierce direct heat is a real technique, not a luxury. Smaller picks earned their badges honestly: a compact grill that a small household will actually use three times a week serves the brief better than a large grill that intimidates its owner.

The 6 Best Options for Best Grills for Grilling & Smoking

Read each review with the same question in mind: how will this grill behave on an ordinary Tuesday, and how will it behave on the one Saturday a month when you want smoke? The strengths and trade-offs are written to answer both.

Nexgrill 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner — best grills for grilling and smoking

Nexgrill 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner

Badge: Best Overall

Strengths

  • Largest confirmed cooking space here at 626 sq. in., so a water pan and a full rack of ribs fit side by side
  • Four burners plus a side burner give the widest two-zone flexibility in the group
  • Stainless steel body with a double-door cabinet keeps chips, boxes, and tools dry and close

Trade-offs

  • Highest total output figure in the group means it drinks propane faster on long cooks
  • Large footprint needs a generous patio corner
  • Stainless surfaces show grease marks and need regular wiping to look their best

At a glance

  • Fuel: propane gas
  • Burners: 4 plus side burner
  • Total output: 60,000 BTU (per listing title)
  • Cooking space: 626 sq. in.
  • Body: stainless steel, double-door cabinet
  • Ignition: electronic
  • Extras: built-in thermometer

The Nexgrill earns Best Overall because room is the resource that grilling and smoking both consume, and this is the roomiest verified design in the set. The listing confirms 626 square inches of cooking space, four main burners, a side burner, electronic ignition, and a built-in thermometer, all wrapped in a stainless steel body with a double-door cabinet. For grilling, that means four independent heat zones: sear steaks over two burners, rest vegetables over a third, and keep finished food warm over the fourth. For a mixed grill night, nothing else here organises the work as calmly.

For the smoking half of the brief, the same layout is what saves it. Light the left burner, place a smoker box over it, set ribs on the right over a water pan, and the cabinet below holds your chips and tongs instead of cluttering the side shelves. Heat retention is helped by the sheer size of the lid, which creates a larger pocket of warm air than a compact grill can. Be honest with yourself about the ceiling, though: this is indirect smoking for ribs, chicken halves, sausages, and fish in the one-to-four-hour range, not an overnight brisket machine.

The honest limitation is running cost and footprint. A big four-burner grill preheats a lot of metal and air for two burgers, and the highest output figure in the group means long low cooks use more propane than a smaller grill would. If your household is two people and your patio is a balcony, the smaller picks below will serve you better. If you regularly cook for six or more and want one grill that grills brilliantly and smokes credibly, this is the pick to beat. Readers comparing sheer capacity should cross-check Best Grills For High Volume as well.

Best for: households that grill for a crowd and smoke ribs, chicken, and fish indirectly / Not suited for: overnight brisket specialists or anyone short on patio space

Check on Amazon

Weber Spirit E-425 Gas Grill — best grills for grilling and smoking

Weber Spirit E-425 Gas Grill

Badge: Best Premium

Strengths

  • Porcelain-enameled cast iron grates hold heat steadily through long indirect cooks
  • Sear Zone with Boost Burners finishes smoked meats with a proper crust
  • Four burners allow a clean hot side and cool side split

Trade-offs

  • Premium-tier positioning in this class
  • Sear features reward attention; food left over boost heat chars quickly
  • No side burner listed, so sauces compete for main-grate space

At a glance

  • Fuel: propane gas
  • Burners: 4
  • Grates: porcelain-enameled cast iron
  • Extras: Sear Zone with Boost Burners, Weber Works rails (per listing title)
  • Finish: black

The Weber Spirit E-425 takes the premium badge on the strength of two confirmed features: porcelain-enameled cast iron grates and a Sear Zone with Boost Burners. Cast iron matters for this brief more than for ordinary grilling. During a long indirect cook, heavy grates act as a heat battery, smoothing the temperature swings that happen every time you lift the lid to mop or turn the food. That steadiness is the difference between ribs that relax and ribs that tighten. The Weber Works rails named in the listing add a tidy accessory system for the tools a smoking session accumulates.

The sear zone is the second half of the argument. A great deal of smoked food is finished, not just smoked: chicken skin needs crisping, a smoked steak wants a final crust, and sausages benefit from thirty seconds of fierce heat at the end. Most gas grills ask you to choose between a good smoke session and a good sear. This design is built to do the smoke gently on the indirect side and then finish hard in the sear zone, which is exactly the workflow experienced cooks use.

The limitation is focus and tier. This is a premium-positioned grill in its class, and its talents point at the main grate: the listing names no side burner, so a pot of sauce or a pan of onions must share grate space or be handled in the kitchen. If your cooking style leans on a side burner every session, the Nexgrill or Electactic below fits better. If your priority is the finest sear-and-smoke combination in this verified set, this is it.

Best for: cooks who smoke gently, then finish with a serious sear / Not suited for: side-burner devotees and buyers who want the lowest-cost design in the class

Check on Amazon

Electactic 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner — best grills for grilling and smoking

Electactic 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner

Badge: Best Mid-Size All-Rounder

Strengths

  • Four burners plus a side burner in a mid-size footprint
  • Stainless steel construction with a built-in thermometer for monitoring indirect cooks
  • Balanced output figure suits both searing and gentle indirect work

Trade-offs

  • Cooking area is not stated in the listing title, so confirm it on the listing
  • Less grate room for a water pan than the largest pick
  • Fewer accessory systems than the premium pick

At a glance

  • Fuel: propane gas
  • Burners: 4 plus side burner
  • Total output: 42,000 BTU (per listing title)
  • Body: stainless steel
  • Extras: built-in thermometer

The Electactic is the quiet middle of this guide, and for many households the middle is exactly right. The listing confirms a stainless steel four-burner design with a side burner, a total output figure of 42,000 BTU, and a built-in thermometer. Four burners is the sweet spot for two-zone cooking: two lit and two off gives a generous indirect area without the fuel appetite of the biggest designs, and the side burner handles the beans, sauces, and finishing glazes that smoking sessions always seem to generate.

In grilling terms, this is the pick for the household that cooks mixed loads: burgers on the hot side, corn on the cool side, sauce warming on the side burner, nothing waiting on anything else. In smoking terms, the built-in thermometer earns its keep, because indirect cooking lives or dies on knowing the temperature at the lid before you trust it with three hours of ribs. Treat any lid thermometer as a guide rather than a laboratory instrument, and confirm with a probe at grate level for important cooks, but having the gauge there at all puts this design ahead of gauge-free rivals.

The honest limitation is unconfirmed cooking area: the listing title does not state a square-inch figure, so check the listing itself and measure your typical load against it before buying. If you routinely cook for more than six, the larger Nexgrill above is the safer choice. If your group is four to six and you want one balanced machine for weeknight grilling and weekend smoke sessions, this all-rounder is the sensible centre of the guide. Skewers fans should also see how it fares in Best Grills For Kabob, where the same burner layout is judged on direct-heat work.

Best for: families of four to six who grill weekly and smoke monthly / Not suited for: very large gatherings or buyers who need a stated, verified cooking area before ordering

Check on Amazon

Charbroil Performance Series 4-Burner Cabinet Grill — best grills for grilling and smoking

Charbroil Performance Series 4-Burner Cabinet Grill

Badge: Best for Cabinet Storage

Strengths

  • Cabinet cart design encloses the tank and your smoking accessories together
  • Four burners plus a side burner support proper two-zone cooking
  • Black finish hides the soot and splatter that smoking sessions produce

Trade-offs

  • Listing title states no cooking area or output figure, so verify both on the listing
  • Cabinet doors add assembly time compared with open-cart designs
  • Enclosed storage needs a wipe-down after greasy cooks to stay fresh

At a glance

  • Fuel: propane gas
  • Burners: 4 plus side burner
  • Style: cabinet cart, black finish
  • Model reference: 463253925 (per listing title)

The Charbroil Performance Series pick earns its badge for something unglamorous that smoking cooks genuinely value: enclosed storage. Smoking, even the light gas-grill kind, accumulates gear. A smoker box, a bag or two of wood chips, a spray bottle, a water pan, tongs, and a brush all need a home, and on an open-cart grill that home is usually the patio floor. This cabinet design, confirmed in the listing with four burners and a side burner in a black finish, swallows the whole kit behind doors, alongside the propane tank it was designed to hide.

As a grill, the four-burner layout does the essential work: a hot side for searing, a cool side for finishing, and enough independently controlled burners to hold a gentle indirect zone for ribs or chicken. The black finish is a practical choice for this brief, because smoke sessions deposit a fine film on every surface and black shows it least. The side burner covers the glaze-and-sauce work that keeps smoked food from drying out while it rests.

The limitation is information, not design: the listing title gives neither a cooking area nor an output figure, so this is the pick you must verify most carefully on the listing page before ordering. Check the stated cooking space against your largest regular cook, and confirm the burner specification matches your expectations. Buyers who prefer every number confirmed in advance should look at the Nexgrill or AMERLIFE-style specification-led listings instead. Buyers who value a tidy patio and a capable four-burner core will find this a very liveable machine.

Best for: tidy cooks who want smoking gear stored inside the grill, not beside it / Not suited for: buyers who need every specification confirmed in the title before shortlisting

Check on Amazon

IdeaMaxx 3-Burner Gas Grill — best grills for grilling and smoking

IdeaMaxx 3-Burner Gas Grill

Badge: Most Portable Gas Pick

Strengths

  • Foldable side shelves shrink its stored footprint dramatically
  • Cast iron grates hold heat well for a grill of this size
  • Three burners still allow a simple two-zone setup

Trade-offs

  • Smaller cooking area limits batch size for both grilling and smoking
  • Three burners give a narrower indirect zone than four-burner designs
  • Cast iron grates need seasoning care to stay rust-free

At a glance

  • Fuel: propane gas
  • Burners: 3
  • Total output: 38,200 BTU (per listing title)
  • Grates: cast iron
  • Extras: foldable side shelves
  • Finish: black

The IdeaMaxx is the pick for cooks whose grilling and smoking happens in more than one place. The listing confirms cast iron grates, a total output figure of 38,200 BTU across three burners, and foldable side shelves, and positions the design for patio and camping use. Fold the shelves down and it stores against a wall or travels in a way the cabinet grills simply cannot. For renters, small-patio owners, and anyone who grills at a campsite or a tailgate as often as at home, that mobility is the feature everything else hangs on.

The cast iron grates deserve emphasis, because they are what keep this small grill credible on the smoking side. Iron holds heat. When you are running one burner low with a smoker box over it and food on the cool side, grate mass steadies the whole system, and when you switch back to direct grilling the same mass produces the deep, even marks that thin grates cannot. Three burners divide neatly into a lit side and an unlit side, which is all a two-zone cook requires.

The honest limitation is scale. A three-burner cooking area serves two to four people comfortably and asks for batch cooking beyond that, and the indirect zone is narrow, so a full rack of ribs may need cutting in half. Cast iron also asks for basic care: dry it, oil it lightly, and it will serve for years; neglect it and it will rust. If your household is small and your space is smaller, those are fair trades. If you feed a crowd weekly, start at the top of this guide instead, and compare notes with Best Grills For Hotdogs if your crowd cooking is mostly fast, direct-heat food.

Best for: small households, renters, and campers who still want cast iron performance / Not suited for: large families or anyone planning long cooks for a crowd

Check on Amazon

Charbroil Classic 3-Burner Gas Grill — best grills for grilling and smoking

Charbroil Classic 3-Burner Gas Grill

Badge: Best for Small Patios

Strengths

  • Compact footprint with a confirmed 360 sq. in. cooking area
  • Porcelain-coated grates are easy to clean after sticky, smoky cooks
  • Side shelves give a small grill proper landing space for trays

Trade-offs

  • Smallest confirmed cooking area in the group
  • Three burners leave a modest indirect zone for smoking
  • No side burner, so all sauce work happens on the main grates or indoors

At a glance

  • Fuel: propane gas
  • Burners: 3
  • Total output: 30,000 BTU (per listing title)
  • Cooking area: 360 sq. in.
  • Grates: porcelain-coated
  • Extras: side shelves

The Charbroil Classic is the smallest confirmed design in this guide, and it is here because small households still deserve an honest grilling and smoking option. The listing confirms three burners, a total output figure of 30,000 BTU, 360 square inches of cooking area, porcelain-coated grates, and side shelves. For one to three people, 360 square inches is not a compromise at all: it holds a full meal in one layer, preheats quickly, and sips propane compared with the big four-burner designs.

For smoking, manage expectations and it will reward you. One burner lit, a small smoker box above it, and chicken thighs, sausages, or a salmon fillet on the unlit side gives you genuine smoke flavour in cooks of an hour or so. Porcelain-coated grates are the right grate choice at this size, because they release sticky, glazed food cleanly and wipe down fast, which matters when the grill lives on a small patio where a messy machine is always in view. The side shelves give you somewhere to put the tray, which small grills too often forget.

The limitation is simply size, stated plainly. There is no side burner, the indirect zone fits small cuts rather than whole racks, and cooking for six means cooking in relays. None of that is a flaw in a grill that never claimed otherwise. Buy it as what it is: the compact, economical-to-run centre of a small household’s outdoor cooking, with light smoking as a genuine bonus rather than a headline promise.

Best for: one-to-three-person households and small patios / Not suited for: crowd cooking, whole racks of ribs, or side-burner cooking

Check on Amazon

Comparison Table

Use this table to compare only what the listings confirm. Where a title states no cooking area, the table says so rather than guessing, and the listing itself is the place to confirm the figure.

Pick Cooking area Burners and output (per listing) Grilling and smoking note Listing
Nexgrill 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner 626 sq. in. 4 burners + side burner, 60,000 BTU total per listing Widest two-zone layout; best indirect-smoking room Check on Amazon
Weber Spirit E-425 Gas Grill Cooking area not stated in listing title 4 burners with Sear Zone and Boost Burners Best grate mass and best finishing sear Check on Amazon
Electactic 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner Cooking area not stated in listing title 4 burners + side burner, 42,000 BTU total per listing Balanced two-zone control with thermometer Check on Amazon
Charbroil Performance Series 4-Burner Cabinet Grill Cooking area not stated in listing title 4 burners + side burner Best enclosed storage for smoking accessories Check on Amazon
IdeaMaxx 3-Burner Gas Grill Cooking area not stated in listing title 3 burners, 38,200 BTU total per listing Foldable shelves; best mobility in the group Check on Amazon
Charbroil Classic 3-Burner Gas Grill 360 sq. in. 3 burners, 30,000 BTU total per listing Most compact; light smoking for small cuts Check on Amazon

How to Choose the Right Grill for Best Grills for Grilling & Smoking

Start by deciding, honestly, what proportion of your cooking is smoking. If the answer is most of it, stop here and buy a dedicated smoker: an offset, a pellet grill, or a bullet smoker will outperform every pick in this guide at low-and-slow work, and no honest guide should talk you out of the right tool. If the answer is that you grill weekly and smoke a few times a season, a gas grill with good two-zone control is the rational single purchase, and the rest of this section is about choosing among them well.

Burner count is really zone count. Three burners give you a hot side and a cool side, which is enough for indirect smoking of small cuts. Four burners give you a wider cool side, room for a water pan beside the food, and the option of a medium zone in between for finishing. A side burner does not smoke anything, but smoking sessions generate side work: glazes to warm, beans to hold, corn to finish. If that work matters to you, weight the side-burner picks more heavily than their badge order suggests.

Grate material decides how steady your indirect cooks feel. Cast iron and porcelain-enameled cast iron store heat and release it slowly, smoothing the swings that follow every lid lift. Porcelain-coated steel grates heat and cool faster, which is fine for direct grilling and forgiving of neglect, but they ask you to be more patient and less curious during a smoke session. Whichever you choose, plan on a smoker box or a pellet tube as part of the purchase: it is the small add-on that turns a gas grill’s indirect zone into a smoking chamber, and no pick in this guide includes one.

Size the grill to your largest regular cook, not your largest imaginable one. Measure the food, not the fantasy: a whole chicken, two racks of ribs cut in half, or a dozen burgers each imply a different cooking area. Remember that indirect cooking halves your usable space, because the food sits only on the unlit side. A grill that feels generous for direct grilling can feel tight the first time you smoke on it, which is why the larger picks lead this guide. Finally, confirm every figure that matters on the listing itself, check the latest price on Amazon, and treat any specification not stated there as unknown rather than assumed.

How to Grill and Smoke on a Gas Grill, Step by Step

Set up for two zones before you light anything. Clear the grates, place a drip pan or water pan on the unlit side where the food will sit, and put your smoker box or filled pellet tube ready over the burner you plan to light. For direct grilling you will light everything; for smoking, light only one side. Preheat with the lid down for ten to fifteen minutes, then brush the grates clean and oil the food, not the grates, to reduce sticking.

To smoke: light one burner (or the outer burner on a four-burner grill) and set it low to medium-low. Place the smoker box directly over the flame and wait until you see a steady, thin wisp of smoke before adding food; white billowing smoke means the wood is combusting rather than smouldering, so give it a minute to settle. Put the food on the unlit side, close the lid, and position the lid vent, where fitted, over the food so smoke is drawn across it. Cook to temperature and tenderness, not to the clock, and resist lifting the lid: every look costs heat and smoke.

To grill: light all burners, preheat fully, and cook in a single layer with space between pieces. Use the hot zone to sear, then move food to a cooler zone to finish without burning. This two-stage method is also the correct finish for smoked food: smoke gently first, then sear briefly at the end for crust and colour. Rest everything before cutting; smoked and grilled meats both repay ten patient minutes under loose foil.

Clean while the grill is still warm. Brush the grates, empty and wash the drip pan once it is cool enough to handle, and wipe the lid interior before soot flakes can season your next meal. Empty the smoker box only when the ash is completely cold. Store chips and pellets dry and sealed; damp wood smoulders poorly and tastes acrid. Troubleshooting: Problem: harsh, bitter smoke flavour → use less wood, wait for thin smoke before adding food, and keep the lid closed so smoke flows rather than stagnates. Problem: temperature will not stay low → turn the lit burner to its lowest setting, crack the lid a fraction for a minute to dump heat, and add a water pan as a heat sink. Problem: food cooks unevenly during indirect cooks → rotate the food halfway through and keep pieces of similar thickness together.

What Gas-Grill Smoking Can and Cannot Do

It helps to name the boundary precisely. Gas-grill smoking excels at adding real smoke flavour to foods that cook in one to four hours: ribs, chicken, sausages, fish, cheese-adjacent appetisers, and vegetables. The flavour is genuine but lighter than offset-smoker barbecue, because the wood burns in a small box rather than as the primary fuel, and the chamber is leakier. For weeknight and weekend cooking, most people find that level of smoke exactly right; competition barbecue is a different pursuit with different equipment.

Where the method reaches its limit is duration and fuel character. Very long cooks consume a lot of propane, demand frequent smoke-source refills, and expose the food to a drier heat than a water-smoker provides. Brisket and large pork shoulders can be cooked indirectly on gas, and many cooks do it happily, but they are the edge case, not the centre. If those cuts are your passion, the honest recommendation stands: pair any of these grills with a dedicated smoker later, and enjoy the best of both rather than forcing one machine to be both.

Wood Choices for a Smoker Box or Pellet Tube

Wood selection matters more than wood quantity. Fruit woods such as apple and cherry give a mild, sweet smoke that suits chicken, fish, and vegetables. Oak and hickory are stronger and stand up to beef and pork; use them with a lighter hand on poultry. Mesquite is the strongest common option and is best kept to short, hot cooks rather than long indirect sessions. Whatever you choose, chips suit a smoker box and short cooks, while pellets in a tube burn longer and steadier for extended sessions.

Soaking chips is a debated habit; dry chips in a hot box begin smoking sooner and more predictably, which most occasional smokers find easier to manage. Replace or refill the smoke source when the smoke stops, not on a timer, and judge by the wisp at the vent rather than by opening the lid. Readers exploring skewer cooking over direct heat will find the wood question framed differently in Best Grills For Kabob, where smoke is a seasoning rather than the method itself.

Setting Up One Grill Station for Both Jobs

Because one machine is doing two jobs, the station around it matters more than usual. Keep the grill on a level, non-combustible surface with clear space on at least one side for a tray landing zone, and store the smoking kit — box or tube, wood, spray bottle, and a spare drip pan — in one container so a smoking session starts in two minutes rather than twenty. Grills with cabinets, like the Charbroil Performance and the larger Nexgrill in this guide, hold that kit inside the cart; open designs need a weatherproof box beside them. Decide where the kit lives before your first smoke session, not during it.

Think about wind as well. A crosswind strips heat from the unlit side and can blow smoke out of the chamber before it crosses the food, which is the most common reason a first gas-grill smoke tastes faint. Position the grill so its back faces the prevailing breeze, keep the lid closed, and let the vent draw smoke across the food. Small placement decisions like these do more for smoke flavour than any accessory, and they cost nothing.

Common Buying Mistakes

The most common mistake is buying a gas grill while believing it is a smoker. It is not, and this guide has said so from the first paragraph. Buy a gas grill for grilling, with smoking as a valued secondary skill, and you will be delighted; buy it expecting offset-smoker results and you will be disappointed no matter which pick you choose.

The second mistake is smoking with every burner lit. Smoke needs a cool side. Food placed over direct flame while a smoker box burns beside it grills and scorches; it does not smoke. Light one side only, keep the food on the other, and let time do the work. The third mistake is chasing thick white smoke. Billowing smoke tastes bitter. Thin, barely visible smoke, sustained patiently, is what flavours food well.

Finally, shoppers routinely buy on burner count alone and ignore grate material and usable indirect area, the two things this brief actually depends on. A four-burner grill with room for a water pan smokes better than a hotter grill with no cool-side space. Read the reviews above for the pick whose trade-offs match your cooking, confirm the details on the listing, and check the latest price on Amazon before you commit.

Final Recommendation

Start with the Nexgrill four-burner if you want the single most complete answer to this brief: the largest confirmed cooking space, a side burner, cabinet storage, and the widest two-zone layout for indirect smoking. Choose the Weber Spirit E-425 instead if finishing matters most to you; its cast iron grates and sear zone produce the best smoke-then-sear results in the group. Choose the Electactic if you want the balanced middle, the Charbroil Performance if tidy enclosed storage is your priority, the IdeaMaxx if the grill must travel or fold away, and the Charbroil Classic if your household and patio are both small.

Whichever you choose, buy the smoker box or pellet tube at the same time, season the grates before the first cook, and keep the honest boundary in mind: these are excellent grills that smoke lightly and well, not smokers that grill. Set that expectation and every pick here will meet it.

Nexgrill 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner · Weber Spirit E-425 Gas Grill · Electactic 4-Burner Gas Grill with Side Burner

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a gas grill really smoke food?

Yes, within limits. With one burner lit, a smoker box or pellet tube over the flame, and food on the unlit side, a gas grill produces genuine smoke flavour on ribs, chicken, fish, and vegetables in cooks of one to four hours. The flavour is lighter than a dedicated smoker and very long cooks are impractical, which is why this guide describes the method as light smoking throughout.

What is the best wood for smoking on a gas grill?

Apple and cherry are the safest starting points: mild, sweet, and forgiving on chicken, fish, and vegetables. Oak and hickory suit beef and pork. Mesquite is strong and best for short cooks. Use chips in a smoker box for shorter sessions and pellets in a tube for longer ones, and wait for thin smoke before adding food.

Do I need a water pan when smoking on gas?

It helps. A water pan on the unlit side steadies the temperature, adds humidity that keeps long-cooking food from drying, and catches drips before they flare. It is not compulsory for short cooks such as sausages or fish, but for ribs and chicken it makes the process noticeably more forgiving.

How long does a propane tank last during smoking?

Low indirect cooking uses far less fuel than full-power grilling, so a standard tank lasts through many smoking sessions. The larger grills in this guide use more fuel to maintain their bigger chambers. Keep a spare tank or a gauge if you cook often; running out mid-cook is the most preventable failure in gas grilling.

Which pick in this guide is closest to a smoker?

None is a smoker, and the guide does not pretend otherwise. The largest pick, the Nexgrill four-burner, gives the most indirect room and therefore the most comfortable smoking sessions. If smoking is your main pursuit, buy a dedicated smoker; if it is a valued extra alongside excellent grilling, any pick here can serve, with the larger designs serving best.

Can I convert one of these grills to natural gas?

Conversion depends on the specific model and must only be done with a manufacturer-approved kit where one exists. Do not assume a propane grill can be converted. Check the listing and the manufacturer documentation for the exact model before planning around a natural gas line.