Disclosure: topratedkitchenware.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission from Amazon and other retailers, at no extra cost to you.
Where to buy
The six models below are the verified picks for this guide to best toilets at menards. Each name links to its Amazon listing, where you can check the latest price on Amazon, confirm the current configuration, and read the newest owner feedback before you decide.
- HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet
- DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet
- BayRoll One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet
- Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet
- TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF)
- MAXSA 15-Inch Elongated Two-Piece Toilet
Read the full guide ↓ for the detailed reviews, the honest limitations of every pick, and the measuring checks that matter more than any headline claim.
Shopping for the best toilets at Menards has a regional flavour the national chains do not: the store serves the Midwest, many of its customers plan projects around a significant drive, and a return trip to exchange a heavy ceramic fixture is a genuinely costly mistake. That makes the specification-first method in this guide especially valuable here. Six verified models are reviewed below, every figure taken from the model’s own listing, with trade-offs stated plainly, so the decision can be made at home, at leisure, before anyone lifts a toilet into a vehicle. A shopper who began with a broader search like Best Toilets Australia will find the same fitting discipline applied to this chain’s context.
The shortlist is built for the range of Midwestern housing this chain serves: older farmhouses and in-town homes with standard rough-ins but varied room sizes, newer builds with chair-height expectations, and small half-baths where a compact fixture is the difference between comfort and knees against the door. It includes a skirted chair-height one-piece, a compact standard-height one-piece for small rooms, a round compact at chair height, an elongated one-piece, an established two-piece with rim-jet flushing, and a lower-seat two-piece for shorter users. Between them, the realistic cases are covered without padding the list with near-duplicates.
Read the reviews with your measurements beside you: rough-in from wall to bolts, clear space in front of the bowl, and the seat height of the toilet you are replacing. Then use the final checks in the how-to-choose section before ordering or travelling. With a regional chain, the goal is a single, correct trip, and this guide is written to make that trip the only one you need.
Key Takeaways
- Plan the purchase fully before travelling; exchanging a toilet is heavy, fragile work.
- Compact picks in this list serve the small half-baths common in older Midwestern homes.
- Both round and elongated bowls appear, because room depth varies more than catalogues admit.
- A lower-seat pick is included for shorter users; chair height is not the only respectful option.
- Verify the model code and box contents from the listing before the trip, not in the car park.
- No prices are printed in this guide; check the live listing figure when you decide.
In this guide
Quick Picks
| Pick | Badge | Why it earns its place | Listing |
|---|---|---|---|
| HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet | Best Overall | Compact skirted one-piece, elongated and chair height, with dual flush. | Check on Amazon |
| DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet | Best for Small Bathrooms | Compact one-piece at standard height, made for small bathrooms. | Check on Amazon |
| BayRoll One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet | Best Compact Round Pick | Compact skirted one-piece with a round bowl and a very light dual-flush setting. | Check on Amazon |
| Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet | Best Elongated One-Piece | Elongated one-piece comfort height with dual flush for water choice. | Check on Amazon |
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF) | Best Established Pick | Established two-piece with rim-jet flushing and a bowl glaze that resists build-up. | Check on Amazon |
| MAXSA 15-Inch Elongated Two-Piece Toilet | Best for Shorter Users | Lower 15-inch seat for shorter users, at a water-saving flush volume. | Check on Amazon |
Shoppers who arrived here from a neighbouring search such as Best Toilets Available will notice the same specification questions recurring, which is reassuring: a toilet that fits your flange, your room, and your household keeps being the right answer however the question is phrased.
How These Picks Were Chosen
Every model in this guide to best toilets at menards comes from a verified pool for this product group, and each one was checked individually before it earned a place. The check is unglamorous but important: the brand and model identity were confirmed, and the working details used throughout this article, from bowl shape and seat height to flush volume and rough-in, were taken from the model’s own listing. Speculation was treated as a defect. If a listing does not state a seat height or a flush rate, the review says that openly and tells you to confirm it on the listing, because a buying guide that invents specifications is worse than one that admits a gap.
With identities confirmed, the six were compared on the ground that matters in a real bathroom. Clearing power was weighted heavily, using the flush architecture each model describes and any standard bulk-test figure the listing publishes. Comfort was treated as a fitting exercise rather than a single ideal: heights in this shortlist range from a low standard seat to an extra-tall bowl, and both round and elongated shapes appear, because households differ. We then scored the ownership chores in our heads the way an owner lives them: how the exterior wipes down, whether the seat is included and soft-closing, how the tank parts can be serviced, and how standard the installation is. Models that were strong in one dimension and weak in another were kept, but their badges and verdicts were written to expose the trade rather than hide it.
This is a research-based guide, not a hands-on laboratory test, and it does not pretend otherwise. It also refuses two common shortcuts. Prices are not printed, because a toilet’s price at any given moment depends on configuration and promotion; the links throughout the guide take you to the live listing, where checking the current figure takes seconds. Fixed scores are not printed either, because a single number cannot tell a tall user and a short user opposite truths about the same seat height. What you get instead is specific: measured details where the listing provides them, labelled gaps where it does not, and a verdict line under every pick.
The 6 Best toilets at menards — Detailed Reviews

HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet
Badge: Best Overall
Strengths
- Compact skirted one-piece body gives an elongated bowl without the visual bulk of many chair-height models
- Dual flush plus a high MaP figure in the listing covers both water saving and confident clearing
- Skirted sides wipe down quickly, with no exposed trapway curves
Trade-offs
- One-piece weight makes solo installation difficult; plan for a second pair of hands
- The full-flush setting is a 1.6-gallon flush, so savings depend on using the light setting often
- At 17.3 inches it is among the taller seats here, which shorter users should test against their comfort
| Detail | Specification from listing |
|---|---|
| Configuration | One-piece, compact skirted design |
| Bowl shape | Elongated |
| Seat height | 17.3 inches, ADA chair height |
| Flush | Dual flush, 1.1 / 1.6 GPF |
| Flush performance note | MaP 1000g (from listing title) |
| Rough-in | 12 inches |
| Colour | White |
What you are looking at in the HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet is a one-piece toilet built around a elongated bowl and a 17.3-inch ADA chair height seat, with dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. Read those four facts as a fitting specification. Height decides daily comfort for the tallest and shortest people in the house. Shape decides sitting room and clearance. Construction decides cleaning and installation. Flush volume decides the water story. This model states its specification honestly in its listing, which makes it easy to place: strong where its specification matches your bathroom, easy to rule out where it does not.
The flush specification, dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush, places this model clearly in the line-up. Households watching water use will read the volume first; households burned by a weak-flushing predecessor will look for the flush system and any published bulk-clearing result before they look at anything else. Both readings are legitimate, and this model gives both readers the information they need in its listing rather than in marketing language. Set up with the correct tank level, it should clear decisively and rinse the bowl in a single cycle. For a Menards shopper, whose store is regional and whose project may be a long drive from the next alternative, the HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet makes sense as a shortlist-first purchase, with the specification settled before the trip.
Two closing checks matter for this pick. First, the fit check: rough-in, bowl projection, and seat height against your room and your household, in that order. Second, the expectation check: the trade-offs listed above are real, and the limitation among them is the one owners in a mismatched household would mention first. If both checks pass, the remaining step is to check the latest price on Amazon and confirm the current configuration before ordering.
Best for: households whose height, bowl-shape, and rough-in measurements match this model’s specification. / Not suited for: buyers whose measurements point to a different height or shape in this shortlist.

DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet
Badge: Best for Small Bathrooms
Strengths
- Compact one-piece footprint is aimed squarely at small bathrooms and powder rooms
- Standard seat height suits shorter users and households with children better than chair-height models
- Dual flush gives a water-saving choice for liquid waste in a small-space design
Trade-offs
- Standard height offers less sit-to-stand help for taller users and those with limited mobility
- A compact body still needs a 12-inch rough-in, so it does not fix a short flange distance
- The listing title does not state bowl shape, so confirm round versus elongated on the listing before ordering
| Detail | Specification from listing |
|---|---|
| Configuration | One-piece, skirted |
| Intended fit | Small bathrooms |
| Seat height | Standard seat height |
| Flush | Dual flush, 1.1 / 1.6 GPF |
| Rough-in | 12 inches |
| Flush character | Described as powerful and quiet in the listing title |
The DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet is a one-piece design with a compact (bowl shape not stated in listing title) bowl and a standard seat height seat position, flushing as dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. That combination defines who it suits before any styling is considered. The seat height is the first filter: it should match the people in your household, not an abstract idea of an upgrade. The bowl shape is the second filter, because it decides both sitting room and how far the fixture reaches into the room. Judged on those two fittings alone, this model earns its place in the shortlist for households whose measurements line up with it, and it should be passed over without regret by households whose measurements do not.
On flushing, the working details are these: the model flushes as dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. Water volume on its own is not a verdict, so weigh it alongside the flush architecture named in the spec box and, where the listing publishes one, its standardised bulk-clearing figure. In everyday terms, a good flush here means the bowl clears in one action, the refill is prompt, and the bowl surface is rinsed well enough that cleaning stays a weekly chore rather than a daily one. For a Menards shopper, whose store is regional and whose project may be a long drive from the next alternative, the DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet makes sense as a shortlist-first purchase, with the specification settled before the trip.
Ownership is where construction shows. As a one-piece design, it carries the cleaning and servicing character of that format, and the honest limitation in the trade-offs list above is the one to weigh seriously rather than skim past. The right buyer reads them and shrugs; the wrong buyer recognises their own bathroom in them. Before ordering, confirm the rough-in in the spec box against your own measurement, confirm whether the seat is included, and check the latest price on Amazon so the figure you decide on is the current one.
Best for: households whose height, bowl-shape, and rough-in measurements match this model’s specification. / Not suited for: buyers whose measurements point to a different height or shape in this shortlist.

BayRoll One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet
Badge: Best Compact Round Pick
Strengths
- Fully skirted sides leave a smooth surface that wipes clean without trapway curves to work around
- The lighter dual-flush setting uses very little water for liquid waste
- Round bowl and compact one-piece body suit smaller bathrooms where an elongated bowl would crowd the room
Trade-offs
- Round bowl gives less sitting room than an elongated bowl, which some adults notice on longer sits
- One-piece bodies are heavy to carry and position, so installation is usually a two-person job
- The low-volume light flush depends on a well-adjusted fill and flush mechanism to stay consistent
| Detail | Specification from listing |
|---|---|
| Configuration | One-piece, fully skirted |
| Bowl shape | Round |
| Seat height | 17 inches, ADA chair height |
| Flush | Dual flush, 0.9 / 1.28 GPF |
| Flush performance note | MaP 1000g (from listing title) |
| Rough-in | 12 inches |
| Seat | Soft-close seat included |
Start with the fit, because the BayRoll One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet makes its case there first. It is a one-piece toilet with a round bowl, a 17-inch ADA chair height seat, and dual flush at 0.9 or 1.28 gallons per flush. If that height matches the users in your home and that bowl shape matches the space in front of your flange, the rest of this review is about confirmation. If either one clashes with your household or your room, no flush system or finish further down the page will rescue the choice, and one of the other five picks will fit you better.
Flush behaviour is the heart of any toilet, and for this model the listing describes dual flush at 0.9 or 1.28 gallons per flush. Treat the volume figure as one input rather than the whole story: clearing depends on how the water is delivered as much as how much is delivered, which is why the spec box records the flush system exactly as the listing names it. Expect the best results when the tank water level is set correctly at installation, a small detail that decides more real-world flush quality than most buyers ever realise. For a Menards shopper, whose store is regional and whose project may be a long drive from the next alternative, the BayRoll One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet makes sense as a shortlist-first purchase, with the specification settled before the trip.
Living with this toilet will be defined less by its best day than by its ordinary ones: the weekly wipe-down, the occasional tank adjustment, the guest who uses the flush control without thinking. On those ordinary measures it is a sound, honestly specified option, provided the trade-offs above do not land on your household’s sore spots. Take the limitation named there seriously; it is the most likely reason this model would disappoint. Measure your rough-in, compare the seat height with your current toilet, and check the latest price on Amazon before you commit.
Best for: households whose height, bowl-shape, and rough-in measurements match this model’s specification. / Not suited for: buyers whose measurements point to a different height or shape in this shortlist.

Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet
Badge: Best Elongated One-Piece
Strengths
- Elongated bowl paired with a chair-height seat is comfortable for taller users and for sitting down and standing up
- One-piece construction removes the tank-to-bowl seam where grime and leaks often start
- Dual flush lets the household save water on liquid waste while keeping a full flush in reserve
Trade-offs
- The full-flush setting uses more water than single-flush water-saving models
- One-piece toilets are awkward and heavy for one person to set onto the flange alone
- Compact one-piece styling still needs the full 12-inch rough-in, so it does not solve a short rough-in
| Detail | Specification from listing |
|---|---|
| Configuration | One-piece |
| Bowl shape | Elongated |
| Seat height | 17 inches, comfort chair height |
| Flush | Dual flush, 1.1 / 1.6 GPF |
| Rough-in | 12 inches |
| Colour | White |
What you are looking at in the Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet is a one-piece toilet built around a elongated bowl and a 17-inch comfort chair height seat, with dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush. Read those four facts as a fitting specification. Height decides daily comfort for the tallest and shortest people in the house. Shape decides sitting room and clearance. Construction decides cleaning and installation. Flush volume decides the water story. This model states its specification honestly in its listing, which makes it easy to place: strong where its specification matches your bathroom, easy to rule out where it does not.
The flush specification, dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush, places this model clearly in the line-up. Households watching water use will read the volume first; households burned by a weak-flushing predecessor will look for the flush system and any published bulk-clearing result before they look at anything else. Both readings are legitimate, and this model gives both readers the information they need in its listing rather than in marketing language. Set up with the correct tank level, it should clear decisively and rinse the bowl in a single cycle. For a Menards shopper, whose store is regional and whose project may be a long drive from the next alternative, the Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet makes sense as a shortlist-first purchase, with the specification settled before the trip.
Two closing checks matter for this pick. First, the fit check: rough-in, bowl projection, and seat height against your room and your household, in that order. Second, the expectation check: the trade-offs listed above are real, and the limitation among them is the one owners in a mismatched household would mention first. If both checks pass, the remaining step is to check the latest price on Amazon and confirm the current configuration before ordering.
Best for: households whose height, bowl-shape, and rough-in measurements match this model’s specification. / Not suited for: buyers whose measurements point to a different height or shape in this shortlist.

TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF)
Badge: Best Established Pick
Strengths
- TORNADO FLUSH uses rim jets to swirl water around the bowl, which helps bowl cleaning on every flush
- CEFIONTECT glaze gives waste less to cling to, so the bowl stays cleaner between scrubs
- Two-piece design means the tank and bowl can be carried separately and a tank part can be replaced on its own
Trade-offs
- At 1.6 gallons per flush it uses more water than 1.28-gallon water-saving models
- The exposed trapway outline collects more dust than a skirted design and takes longer to wipe down
- Universal Height will feel tall to shorter users and to children compared with a standard-height bowl
| Detail | Specification from listing |
|---|---|
| Configuration | Two-piece |
| Bowl shape | Elongated |
| Seat height | Universal Height |
| Flush | 1.6 GPF, TORNADO FLUSH |
| Bowl surface | CEFIONTECT glaze |
| Model | CST776CSFG#01 |
| Colour | Cotton White |
The TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF) is a two-piece design with a elongated bowl and a Universal Height seat position, flushing as single flush at 1.6 gallons per flush with TORNADO FLUSH. That combination defines who it suits before any styling is considered. The seat height is the first filter: it should match the people in your household, not an abstract idea of an upgrade. The bowl shape is the second filter, because it decides both sitting room and how far the fixture reaches into the room. Judged on those two fittings alone, this model earns its place in the shortlist for households whose measurements line up with it, and it should be passed over without regret by households whose measurements do not.
On flushing, the working details are these: the model flushes as single flush at 1.6 gallons per flush with TORNADO FLUSH. Water volume on its own is not a verdict, so weigh it alongside the flush architecture named in the spec box and, where the listing publishes one, its standardised bulk-clearing figure. In everyday terms, a good flush here means the bowl clears in one action, the refill is prompt, and the bowl surface is rinsed well enough that cleaning stays a weekly chore rather than a daily one. For a Menards shopper, whose store is regional and whose project may be a long drive from the next alternative, the TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF) makes sense as a shortlist-first purchase, with the specification settled before the trip.
Ownership is where construction shows. As a two-piece design, it carries the cleaning and servicing character of that format, and the honest limitation in the trade-offs list above is the one to weigh seriously rather than skim past. The right buyer reads them and shrugs; the wrong buyer recognises their own bathroom in them. Before ordering, confirm the rough-in in the spec box against your own measurement, confirm whether the seat is included, and check the latest price on Amazon so the figure you decide on is the current one.
Best for: households whose height, bowl-shape, and rough-in measurements match this model’s specification. / Not suited for: buyers whose measurements point to a different height or shape in this shortlist.

MAXSA 15-Inch Elongated Two-Piece Toilet
Badge: Best for Shorter Users
Strengths
- The 15-inch seat height suits shorter users, children, and anyone who finds chair-height bowls uncomfortably tall
- 1.28-gallon siphonic flush keeps water use at the common water-saving level
- Soft-close seat is included, so there is no separate seat purchase to match
Trade-offs
- The lower seat is harder on knees for taller users and for people who rely on a higher seat to stand
- Siphonic flushing is quieter but can be less forceful on stubborn loads than high-velocity systems
- Two-piece styling shows the trapway contour, which takes more effort to keep dust-free
| Detail | Specification from listing |
|---|---|
| Configuration | Two-piece |
| Bowl shape | Elongated |
| Seat height | 15 inches |
| Flush | 1.28 GPF siphonic flush |
| Rough-in | 12 inches |
| Seat | Soft-close seat included |
| Material | White ceramic |
Start with the fit, because the MAXSA 15-Inch Elongated Two-Piece Toilet makes its case there first. It is a two-piece toilet with a elongated bowl, a 15-inch seat height seat, and single flush at 1.28 gallons per flush with a siphonic flush. If that height matches the users in your home and that bowl shape matches the space in front of your flange, the rest of this review is about confirmation. If either one clashes with your household or your room, no flush system or finish further down the page will rescue the choice, and one of the other five picks will fit you better.
Flush behaviour is the heart of any toilet, and for this model the listing describes single flush at 1.28 gallons per flush with a siphonic flush. Treat the volume figure as one input rather than the whole story: clearing depends on how the water is delivered as much as how much is delivered, which is why the spec box records the flush system exactly as the listing names it. Expect the best results when the tank water level is set correctly at installation, a small detail that decides more real-world flush quality than most buyers ever realise. For a Menards shopper, whose store is regional and whose project may be a long drive from the next alternative, the MAXSA 15-Inch Elongated Two-Piece Toilet makes sense as a shortlist-first purchase, with the specification settled before the trip.
Living with this toilet will be defined less by its best day than by its ordinary ones: the weekly wipe-down, the occasional tank adjustment, the guest who uses the flush control without thinking. On those ordinary measures it is a sound, honestly specified option, provided the trade-offs above do not land on your household’s sore spots. Take the limitation named there seriously; it is the most likely reason this model would disappoint. Measure your rough-in, compare the seat height with your current toilet, and check the latest price on Amazon before you commit.
Best for: households whose height, bowl-shape, and rough-in measurements match this model’s specification. / Not suited for: buyers whose measurements point to a different height or shape in this shortlist.
Comparison Table
| Pick | Type | Bowl | Seat height | Flush | Listing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet | one-piece | elongated | 17.3-inch ADA chair height | dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush | Check on Amazon |
| DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet | one-piece | compact (bowl shape not stated in listing title) | standard seat height | dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush | Check on Amazon |
| BayRoll One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet | one-piece | round | 17-inch ADA chair height | dual flush at 0.9 or 1.28 gallons per flush | Check on Amazon |
| Casta Diva Elongated One Piece Toilet | one-piece | elongated | 17-inch comfort chair height | dual flush at 1.1 or 1.6 gallons per flush | Check on Amazon |
| TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF) | two-piece | elongated | Universal Height | single flush at 1.6 gallons per flush with TORNADO FLUSH | Check on Amazon |
| MAXSA 15-Inch Elongated Two-Piece Toilet | two-piece | elongated | 15-inch seat height | single flush at 1.28 gallons per flush with a siphonic flush | Check on Amazon |
Read the table as a fitting chart rather than a league table: the right row is the one whose height, shape, and flush pattern match your bathroom and household. Readers comparing this chart with Best Toilets Bowl should apply the same fitting logic there.
How to Choose the Right Toilet for Your Bathroom
Start with the measurement you cannot negotiate: the rough-in. This is the distance from the finished wall behind the toilet to the centre of the floor flange bolts, and it decides which toilets can physically be installed in your bathroom. Twelve inches is the modern standard, and most of the models in this guide are built for it. Older homes sometimes have a ten-inch or even a fourteen-inch rough-in. Measure before you fall in love with a model: remove nothing, simply measure from the wall (not the skirting board) to the centre of the visible bolt caps on the existing toilet, and match that number to the rough-in in the spec box. A toilet bought for the wrong rough-in is not a bargain at any price; it is a return shipment.
Bowl shape is the second decision, and it is about space and sitting room. An elongated bowl gives more seat area front to back and is the comfort favourite for most adults, but it reaches further into the room. A round bowl is shorter, which can be the difference between a door that swings freely and one that clips knees in a small bathroom. Measure the space in front of the flange as well: building guidance generally wants clear floor space in front of the bowl, and a compact or round model can rescue a tight layout. Neither shape flushes inherently better; shape is a fit decision, not a performance decision.
Seat height deserves more thought than most buyers give it. Standard height, around fifteen inches at the seat, suits shorter users and children, and lets feet rest flat, which many people find more natural. Chair height, roughly seventeen to nineteen inches, lines up with the accessibility guidance used for grab-bar bathrooms and makes sitting down and standing up easier for taller people, older users, and anyone with knee or hip limitations. The extra-tall end of the range is a genuine help to the right household and genuinely awkward for the wrong one. If several people share the bathroom, choose for the person who struggles most with the current toilet, and remember that a seat adds a little height of its own on top of the bowl figure.
Flush performance is where specifications actually help. Water volume is stated in gallons per flush: 1.28 is the common water-saving level, 1.6 is the older full-volume standard, and dual-flush models offer a reduced setting for liquid waste alongside a full setting. Volume alone does not tell you how well a toilet clears, which is why many listings also publish a MaP figure, a standardised bulk-clearing test result measured in grams; higher figures indicate stronger single-flush clearing in that test. Flush architecture matters too. Siphonic designs pull waste through with a quieter, swirling action, while high-velocity rim-jet systems scour the bowl as they flush, which helps keep the bowl cleaner between scrubs. Pick the combination that matches your priority: lowest water use, strongest clearing, quietest operation, or easiest bowl cleaning.
Construction decides your cleaning routine and your installation day. A one-piece toilet casts tank and bowl as a single unit: no seam to trap grime or leak, a sleeker outline, and often a skirted base that wipes down in seconds, at the cost of a heavier lift and usually a higher tier. A two-piece toilet bolts a separate tank onto the bowl: lighter to carry piece by piece, easier to source a replacement tank or internal parts for, and typically the better value, at the cost of more contours to dust and a seam to seat correctly at installation. Skirted sides, on either construction, hide the trapway outline and are the single biggest cleaning convenience you can buy. Also confirm what is in the box: a matched soft-close seat and, on some models, an installation kit with a wax ring save a second shopping trip.
Add a regional practical check to the standard list: confirm how you will get the fixture home and the old one out. A one-piece toilet is a two-person lift into and out of a vehicle, and rural properties add distance to every part of that errand. If help is scarce, the two-piece picks in this list, which travel as two lighter boxes, may be the wiser engineering choice regardless of style. The same logistics-first thinking applies when comparing with Best Toilets Business Insider.
Finally, think about the unglamorous ownership details before you order. Check that your water supply stop and its connection will reach the new tank inlet, and note whether the flush control is a lever, a side push, or a top button, because guests and children handle familiar controls best. If you may add a bidet seat later, a model described as ready for one from the same brand keeps that upgrade tidy. And plan the swap itself: you will need the old toilet removed, the flange inspected, and a new wax ring or seal regardless of what the new box includes. Choosing well is mostly measuring honestly and matching the toilet to the people who will use it every day.
How to Fit and Maintain a New Toilet
Most toilet replacements fail, when they fail, on preparation rather than on the fixture itself: a rough-in measured from the skirting board, a flange left sitting below floor level, or floor nuts wrenched down hard enough to stress the ceramic. Work through the steps in order, keep the old towels closer than you think you need them, and test everything before you tidy up.
- Measure and confirm fit. Check the rough-in from wall to flange bolts, the clear space in front of the bowl, and the width available, then compare all three against the chosen model’s spec box.
- Prepare the room. Turn off the water at the stop valve, flush to empty the tank, sponge out remaining bowl water, and lay down an old towel or cardboard where the new toilet will be set.
- Remove the old toilet. Disconnect the supply line, undo the floor nuts, rock the bowl gently to break the old seal, and lift it clear with help. Scrape the flange clean and inspect it for cracks or a low seating surface.
- Set the new seal and bowl. Fit a new wax ring or approved seal onto the flange or bowl outlet as the instructions direct, lower the bowl straight onto the bolts without twisting, and press down evenly so the seal compresses uniformly.
- Secure and connect. Tighten the floor nuts alternately, snug rather than forced, since overtightening can crack the ceramic base. Attach the tank on a two-piece model with its seal seated, connect the supply line, and turn the water back on slowly.
- Test before finishing. Let the tank fill, check every joint and the base perimeter for moisture, flush several times, and watch the bowl clear and refill correctly. Only then fit bolt caps and, if you use it, a thin bead of sealant around the front and sides of the base, leaving the back unsealed so a leak can show itself.
Weekly care is simple and mostly about not damaging the surfaces that keep the bowl clean. Wipe the exterior, including around the base and behind the tank on a two-piece model, with a soft cloth and a mild cleaner; skirted models make this a one-minute job. Clean the bowl with a toilet brush and a non-abrasive bowl cleaner, working under the rim where deposits form. Avoid in-tank drop-in tablets with harsh chemicals, which can degrade flappers and seals inside the tank and shorten the life of the flush mechanism. Every few months, lift the tank lid and look inside: the water level should sit at the marked line, the flapper or seal should sit flat, and nothing should be running silently. A toilet that refills briefly on its own between flushes is telling you a seal is passing water, and fixing that small part early protects your water bill.
Problem: The toilet flushes weakly or needs a second flush. → Check the tank water level first; a low level is the most common cause and is adjusted at the fill valve. Then look for a worn flapper or a slack chain that is not lifting the flush mechanism fully.
Problem: Water runs or the tank refills on its own. → Remove the lid and watch the flush seal seat after a flush. Debris under the seal or a perished flapper lets water seep into the bowl; cleaning or replacing that inexpensive part usually ends the running.
Problem: Moisture appears around the base. → Do not simply caulk over it. Moisture at the base can mean the wax seal has failed, and the correct fix is to lift the toilet, replace the seal, and check the flange height and condition before resetting it.
One Trip, Done Right: Planning a Menards Toilet Purchase
The economics of a regional chain reward preparation. Before travelling or ordering, complete four tasks at home: measure the rough-in and the room, sit on your current toilet and decide honestly whether its height works for your household, photograph the existing installation including the supply stop, and choose your pick plus one fallback from this shortlist. With those four done, the store visit becomes a verification exercise, model code, box contents, seat included, rather than a decision made under fluorescent lights. The neighbouring guide at Best Toilets By Consumer Reports assumes the same prepare-first approach, because the cost of a wrong toilet is mostly the cost of moving it twice.
Inspect the porcelain before you leave the car park if you are collecting in person. A chip found at home, an hour from the store, is a far larger problem than the same chip found at the kerb. Keep the packaging intact until the new toilet has been installed and flushed several times.
Toilets for Older Midwestern Homes
Older housing stock brings a predictable set of toilet challenges: floors that are not perfectly level, flanges that have been repaired before, supply stops that have not been turned in years, and bathrooms smaller than modern building habits assume. None of these rule out a modern toilet, but they argue for the forgiving end of this shortlist: two-piece designs that are easier to manoeuvre into a tight room, standard rough-ins confirmed by measurement rather than assumed, and compact models where the room demands them. Turn the supply stop gently a week before installation day, so a seized valve is discovered while it is still a small plumbing job rather than a mid-swap emergency.
Common Buying Mistakes
Measuring the rough-in from the skirting board. The measurement runs from the finished wall to the centre of the flange bolts. Including the skirting board shortens your figure and can leave you with a toilet that will not sit back correctly, or a gap you did not expect.
Buying height by habit. Many shoppers replace a standard-height toilet with a chair-height model because it sounds like an upgrade, then discover shorter household members dislike it. Height is a fit choice for the people in the house, not a trim level.
Judging flush power by water volume alone. A higher gallon figure does not guarantee better clearing, and a lower one does not guarantee weakness. Look at the flush system and any standardised bulk-clearing figure the listing publishes, not just the volume.
Forgetting the seat and the seal. Some models include a matched soft-close seat and even an installation kit; others include neither. Assuming the box contains everything leads to a second trip and a toilet sitting uninstalled in the hallway.
Sealing the whole base shut. Caulking all the way around the base, including the back, hides a failing wax seal by trapping its leak under the floor covering. Leave the back unsealed so any problem announces itself visibly.
Ignoring the room around the toilet. Door swing, vanity drawers, and the clear space in front of the bowl all interact with bowl length. An elongated model that fits the flange can still be the wrong choice for the room.
Final Recommendation
If you want one answer first: begin with the HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet, which carries the Best Overall badge in this guide because its specification suits the widest range of households shopping this search. Then sanity-check it against your own measurements before ordering. If its height or bowl shape does not fit your household, move to the pick whose badge matches your situation rather than forcing the headline choice.
For most households in this chain’s territory, the leading skirted chair-height pick is the strongest all-round answer. Small half-baths should start with the compact standard-height pick, and households replacing a toilet in an older home should favour the forgiving two-piece picks and confirm the flange before committing.
Our three most-visited listings from this shortlist are HOROW T0338W One Piece Toilet, DeerValley Compact One Piece Toilet, BayRoll One Piece Sleek Modern Toilet. Each link takes you to the live listing, where you can check the latest price on Amazon and confirm rough-in, seat inclusion, and configuration one last time. Shoppers still weighing a neighbouring question, such as Best Toilets Cadet 3, can carry the same shortlist across; the fitting checks do not change.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should I check before driving to buy a toilet from a regional chain?
Four things: your rough-in measurement, the clear space in front of the bowl, whether the seat height you want is the one your household actually prefers, and the exact model code of your chosen pick with its box contents. Add a plan for moving the fixture, since a one-piece toilet is a two-person lift, and inspect the porcelain before leaving, because a return trip with a heavy ceramic fixture is the outcome the whole plan exists to avoid.
What is the difference between chair height and standard height?
Standard-height bowls sit at roughly fifteen inches at the seat, while chair-height bowls sit at roughly seventeen to nineteen inches, in line with the seat heights used in accessible bathrooms. Taller seats make sitting and standing easier for tall users and for people with limited mobility, while lower seats let shorter users and children rest their feet flat. Choose for the household member who finds the current toilet hardest to use.
Is a one-piece or a two-piece toilet better?
Neither is better in absolute terms; they trade different things. A one-piece toilet has no tank seam, often has skirted sides that clean quickly, and looks sleeker, but it is heavier to install. A two-piece toilet is easier to carry in parts, simpler to source replacement tank components for, and usually sits in a lower tier. Decide by your cleaning patience, your installation help, and how long you plan to keep the fixture.
What does a MaP figure tell me about a toilet?
MaP is a standardised bulk-clearing test that measures how much test material a toilet removes in a single flush, reported in grams. Where a listing publishes a high MaP figure, it is evidence of confident clearing in that test protocol. It is one useful signal among several, alongside flush design and water volume, and listings that do not publish a figure are not automatically weak; the detail simply has not been stated.
Does a dual-flush toilet really save water?
It can, provided the household actually uses the reduced setting for liquid waste, which is the majority of flushes in most homes. The saving comes from behaviour as much as hardware. If your household will not bother choosing between two buttons, a well-designed single-flush model at a water-saving volume may serve you just as well in practice.


