Skip to content
RESEARCH-BASED GUIDES. PRACTICAL EVERYDAY ADVICE.How we pick products
TKTop Rated KitchenwareA more thoughtful kitchen
Toilets

Best Toilets To Get

We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases. How we pick products

Where to buy

Check the latest price, availability and delivery on Amazon. Orders are placed on Amazon. We may earn a commission from qualifying purchases.

See 4 more Amazon options
Read the full guide ↓

Disclosure: topratedkitchenware.com is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission from Amazon and other retailers, at no extra cost to you.

Where to buy

Short on time? This is the shortlist behind our guide to the best toilets to get, in ranked order. Linked names open the product’s online listing, where you can check the latest price on Amazon and confirm the full specification before you buy.

Read the full guide ↓

Introduction: Toilets to get — what actually matters

The best toilets to get is the broadest question in this category — no single attribute, just: I need a toilet, which one should actually arrive at my house? The honest answer is that the right toilet depends on the room it must serve, and this pool happens to contain a genuine spread of answers: a benchmark gravity toilet, a mainstream efficiency model, two macerating systems for rooms without drains, a smart bidet toilet, and a portable unit for no-plumbing situations.

Rather than pretend one winner fits every bathroom, this guide organises the six by the situation each is built for, with every pick linked and every listing claim kept inside what the verified titles actually state. If your project is a straightforward replacement, the gravity pair lead. If your project is adding a bathroom where none can normally go, the macerators lead. The smart and portable picks serve comfort-first and plumbing-free briefs respectively. Readers comparing the neighbouring question of Best Ways To Get Tough Stains Off Toilets will find the same evidence standards applied there.

Start by identifying your room honestly — drain position, water supply, power, and who uses it — and the shortlist below will narrow itself to one or two names quickly.

Key Takeaways

  • Match the toilet to the room’s infrastructure first: floor drain, no drain, or no plumbing at all.
  • The TOTO Drake is the default recommendation for a conventional replacement — proven flush system, glazed bowl, mainstream format.
  • The MAXSA covers the modern mainstream brief: 1.28-gallon efficiency, comfort height, soft-close seat, standard rough-in.
  • Macerating picks exist for adding bathrooms in basements and conversions where gravity cannot go.
  • Smart and portable picks are specialist answers — bidet comfort, and camping or emergency use — not general replacements.
In this guide

Quick Picks: best toilets to get

Pick Badge Stated highlights Link
Simple Project Upgrade 600W Macerating Toilet System Best for Basement Additions Type: macerating upflush system with pump; Motor: 600W macerator; Inlets: 3 water inlets plus AC vent Check on Amazon
Simple Project 600W Macerating Toilet System Best One-Piece Macerator Type: macerating upflush system with pump; Motor: 600W macerator; Inlets: 3 water inlets plus AC vent Check on Amazon
Ann Katy Upgrade XL Portable Toilet Best No-Plumbing Option Type: portable camping toilet, no plumbing; Size: XL, extra large stated; Features: lid stated, lightweight and compact stated Check on Amazon
TDH Luxury Smart Toilet with Built-In Bidet Best Smart Comfort Pick Type: one-piece smart toilet with built-in bidet; Features stated: instant warm water, dryer, heated seat functions; Display: larger LED display stated Check on Amazon
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF) Best Overall Toilet to Get Type: two-piece gravity toilet; Flush: TORNADO FLUSH, 1.6 gallons per flush; Bowl: elongated, Universal Height Check on Amazon
MAXSA Elongated Two-Piece Toilet Best Mainstream Value Pick Type: two-piece gravity toilet; Flush: siphonic, 1.28 gallons per flush, stated water-saving; Bowl: elongated, comfort height Check on Amazon

How These Picks Were Chosen

With a keyword this open, method matters more than ranking: we sorted the pool by installation reality before product quality. Gravity toilets were judged on stated flush system, volume and format; macerators on pump power, inlets and venting; the smart toilet on its stated feature set with its unstated flush volume flagged; the portable on the travel and emergency brief its listing actually describes. No pick was credited with a capability outside its verified title. If your shortlist widens, Best Toilets Ranked is the companion comparison built for that angle.

The verified product pool for this guide was checked through the Amazon Creators API on 2026-11-20: every linked ASIN, product title and image in this article comes from that verified pool, and nothing has been added from memory, from another site, or from a retailer listing we could not verify. Specifications are quoted only where the verified title states them; where a title is silent — on a flush volume, a rough-in, a dimension — the review flags the silence instead of filling it with a plausible number.

Within each situation the ranking follows stated evidence and household fit, and the verdicts say plainly who should skip each pick. This is research-led guidance built from manufacturer listings and category knowledge — not hands-on testing — and prices are deliberately absent, since the right toilet at a checked-current price beats a wrong one at a remembered discount.

The 6 Best Toilets to get

Simple Project Upgrade 600W Macerating Toilet System — best toilets to get

Simple Project Upgrade 600W Macerating Toilet System

Badge: Best for Basement Additions

Strengths

  • Updated version of the 600W platform with the same three-inlet flexibility
  • Lets a basement gain a flushing toilet where gravity drainage cannot reach
  • Quiet operation is stated in the listing, relevant for bathrooms near living space

Trade-offs

  • Flush volume is not stated in the verified listing title, so water use cannot be compared from the title alone
  • Electric pump dependence and macerator-only waste rules apply, as with the whole class
  • Vent and power routing still need planning before purchase

Key specifications (as stated in the verified listing):

  • Type: macerating upflush system with pump
  • Motor: 600W macerator
  • Inlets: 3 water inlets plus AC vent
  • Stated positioning: basement upflush installation

The Upgrade 600W system is Simple Project’s refreshed take on its mid-power macerator: three inlets, a vent connection, and a pump sized for one added bathroom. It suits the classic problem — a basement, garage conversion or under-stairs space where the sewer line is above the floor or too far away for a gravity fall. Because the discharge travels through narrow pipe under pressure, the pipe run can climb and turn in ways a soil pipe cannot. What the verified title does not state is a flush volume, so any water-use comparison has to come from the full listing rather than assumption.

As a toilet to get, this one answers the hardest brief: a real flushing toilet in a basement that has no floor drain. The vented 600W pump and three inlets cover a small added bathroom completely. Get it when the room is the problem; skip it when a normal drain already exists and a gravity toilet would be simpler.

Its owners buy a room, not a fixture — the basement bathroom that raises the house’s usefulness every single day. The pump’s overhead reads differently against that return: it is the rent the room pays for existing.

Best for: adding a basement bathroom without a floor drain / Not suited for: homes with a standard drain and no need for a pump

Check on Amazon

Simple Project 600W Macerating Toilet System — best toilets to get

Simple Project 600W Macerating Toilet System

Badge: Best One-Piece Macerator

Strengths

  • Proven mid-power macerator format for adding a basement bathroom without floor demolition
  • Three inlets plus a vent connection cover a toilet, sink and shower combination
  • Rear-outlet bowl keeps the discharge path short and hidden behind the unit

Trade-offs

  • The stated flush volume is the older full-volume figure, so it is not a water-saving design
  • Needs a power outlet near the unit and a vent path, which not every basement corner offers
  • As with all macerators, wipes and non-paper items are strictly off limits

Key specifications (as stated in the verified listing):

  • Type: macerating upflush system with pump
  • Motor: 600W macerator
  • Inlets: 3 water inlets plus AC vent
  • Outlet: rear outlet bowl
  • Flush volume stated: 1.6 gallons per flush

This 600W Simple Project system is the middleweight upflush option: the same basic idea as its stronger sibling — grind, then pump — sized for a single added bathroom rather than a whole suite. The listing states three water inlets and an AC vent connection, a rear-outlet bowl, and connections intended to also serve a sink and shower. For a basement conversion that is the practical package: one pump, one small discharge line run up to the house drain, and no jackhammer work on the slab. The trade is dependence on power and on the macerator rules — only waste and toilet paper go in, ever.

The one-piece macerator is the tidier way to buy the same capability — rear-outlet bowl, 600W pump, sink and shower inlets — in a form that looks like a designed bathroom rather than equipment. Its stated full-volume flush suits homes with ample water; efficiency shoppers should note that figure before choosing it.

In a finished basement it disappears into the household like any bathroom, which is its design’s victory. The full-volume flush is the one number its owners should watch with metered water — a known cost, chosen openly.

Best for: finished basement bathrooms wanting one-piece looks / Not suited for: water-efficiency priorities

Check on Amazon

Ann Katy Upgrade XL Portable Toilet — best toilets to get

Ann Katy Upgrade XL Portable Toilet

Badge: Best No-Plumbing Option

Strengths

  • Needs no water supply, drain or installation of any kind
  • XL sizing makes it more usable for adults than miniature camping potties
  • Lightweight and compact for transport and storage

Trade-offs

  • It is a camping and emergency product, not a bathroom toilet — no flush system or sewer connection
  • Waste must be emptied and the unit cleaned manually after use
  • No seat height, capacity or flush mechanism is stated in the verified title

Key specifications (as stated in the verified listing):

  • Type: portable camping toilet, no plumbing
  • Size: XL, extra large stated
  • Features: lid stated, lightweight and compact stated
  • Users stated: adults and kids
  • Settings stated: hiking, beach, boat, emergency and RV use

The Ann Katy Upgrade XL is a portable camping toilet: a lidded, lightweight unit with no plumbing, no flush system and no connection to any drain. The listing positions it for hiking, beach trips, boats, RV use and emergencies, in an extra-large size intended to be more practical for adults than the smallest camping potties, and suitable for kids as well. Everything about it is manual — set it down, use it, empty it, clean it. That simplicity is exactly its value in the settings it was built for, and exactly its limit everywhere else.

Get this when the requirement is a toilet with no installation, no plumbing and no delay: camping, a boat, a site cabin, an emergency backup for a home whose bathroom is out of action. It is honestly not a bathroom replacement, and its presence here marks the boundary of what the word toilet can usefully cover.

Its ledger is the shortest in the pool: no parts, no water, no power, just a unit that is emptied and rinsed. For the uses it serves, that near-zero ownership is precisely the recommendation — and for a home bathroom, precisely the disqualification.

Best for: camping, boats, sites and emergency backup / Not suited for: a permanent home bathroom

Check on Amazon

TDH Luxury Smart Toilet with Built-In Bidet — best toilets to get

TDH Luxury Smart Toilet with Built-In Bidet

Badge: Best Smart Comfort Pick

Strengths

  • The only pick with a built-in bidet, warm water, heated seat and dryer in one unit
  • Auto flushing and a foot sensor give hands-reduced operation
  • One-piece body has no tank seam and wipes down easily

Trade-offs

  • No flush volume or flush performance figure is stated in the verified title
  • Needs a power outlet and the most involved installation of any pick here
  • Electronics add failure modes a plain gravity toilet simply does not have

Key specifications (as stated in the verified listing):

  • Type: one-piece smart toilet with built-in bidet
  • Features stated: instant warm water, dryer, heated seat functions
  • Display: larger LED display stated
  • Flush: leave-seat auto flushing and foot sensor stated
  • Extras: night light stated
  • Cleaning: multiple cleaning modes stated

The TDH is the technology outlier: a one-piece smart toilet with a built-in bidet, instant warm water, a dryer and heated-seat functions, a larger LED display, leave-seat auto flushing, a foot sensor, a night light and multiple cleaning modes — all stated in the listing. As a comfort appliance it operates in a different league from a plain ceramic bowl. What the verified title does not state is any flush volume or flush performance figure, so its waste-clearing credentials cannot be compared with the scored and specified gravity picks from the title alone; the full listing is where that check has to happen.

Get the TDH when the purchase is really about the experience: bidet washing with warm water, a heated seat, drying, auto flushing and a night light in one one-piece unit. Its listing does not state flush volume, so a buyer for whom clearing performance is paramount should verify that figure on the full listing — the comfort specification, by contrast, is stated in full.

Ownership is appliance ownership: firmware-era features, a remote or display, seals and electronics on a service horizon shorter than the ceramic’s. Buyers who enter it as they would a washing machine — delighted, and unsurprised by eventual servicing — are its happy owners.

Best for: bidet comfort and smart features as the priority / Not suited for: buyers who need stated flush volume up front

Check on Amazon

TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF) — best toilets to get

TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF)

Badge: Best Overall Toilet to Get

Strengths

  • TORNADO FLUSH uses rim jets to swirl the full bowl, a design built around clearing power
  • CEFIONTECT glaze gives waste and mineral residue a smoother, less adhesive surface
  • Full 1.6-gallon volume carries a strong drainline push for older plumbing

Trade-offs

  • Uses more water per flush than the 1.28-gallon efficiency class
  • Two-piece construction has a tank-to-bowl seam that one-piece designs avoid
  • Seat and rough-in details are not stated in the verified title and must be checked on the listing

Key specifications (as stated in the verified listing):

  • Type: two-piece gravity toilet
  • Flush: TORNADO FLUSH, 1.6 gallons per flush
  • Bowl: elongated, Universal Height
  • Surface: CEFIONTECT glaze
  • Colour: Cotton White
  • Model: CST776CSFG#01

The TOTO Drake is the reference point for gravity flushing in this group. Its TORNADO FLUSH system drives water through rim jets so the bowl is scrubbed by a swirling flush rather than a simple dump from the tank, and the full 1.6-gallon volume gives the drainline a strong carrying push — a combination that suits houses with older, longer or rougher drain runs. The CEFIONTECT glaze is the other half of the story: an extra-smooth ceramic surface that waste and mineral deposits stick to less readily, so the bowl stays cleaner between scrubs. Universal Height and an elongated bowl put it in the comfort mainstream for adult households.

The default get. For the ordinary replacement project — old toilet out, new toilet in, on a standard floor drain — the Drake’s combination of a named flush system, a residue-resistant glaze, full stated volume and a mainstream two-piece format is the lowest-regret specification in this pool, which is why it carries the overall badge.

The Drake’s ownership story is the category’s ideal: nothing to report. Years pass, a flapper eventually changes, the glaze keeps the bowl presentable, and the flush stays the flush. Most households want exactly this story and should be suspicious of any more exciting one.

Best for: the standard replacement project on a floor drain / Not suited for: strict water conservation

Check on Amazon

MAXSA Elongated Two-Piece Toilet — best toilets to get

MAXSA Elongated Two-Piece Toilet

Badge: Best Mainstream Value Pick

Strengths

  • Stated water-saving 1.28-gallon siphonic flush in a mainstream comfort format
  • Easy-clean ceramic is stated in the listing, which helps with routine bowl care
  • Comfort height, elongated bowl, soft-close seat and standard rough-in are all stated in one package

Trade-offs

  • Siphonic flushes trade some raw push for quieter operation compared with washdown designs
  • The listing pairs a 15-inch figure with a comfort-height description — verify exact seat height on the full listing
  • A newer name in toilets, without the long model history of the biggest brands

Key specifications (as stated in the verified listing):

  • Type: two-piece gravity toilet
  • Flush: siphonic, 1.28 gallons per flush, stated water-saving
  • Bowl: elongated, comfort height
  • Seat: soft-close seat stated
  • Rough-in: 12 inch stated
  • Surface: easy-clean white ceramic stated

The MAXSA entry is the straightforward modern specification: an elongated, comfort-height, two-piece toilet with a siphonic flush at the 1.28-gallon water-saving volume, a soft-close seat and the standard 12-inch rough-in, all stated plainly in the listing. The easy-clean ceramic callout matters for daily life — bowls that release residue easily need less aggressive scrubbing and fewer harsh chemicals. Siphonic action fills and pulls the bowl contents through the trapway in one motion, which tends to run quieter than high-velocity washdown designs, a real consideration for bathrooms off bedrooms.

Get the MAXSA when the brief is a modern, efficient, comfortable toilet without drama: stated 1.28-gallon siphonic flush, comfort height, soft-close seat, easy-clean ceramic and the standard rough-in. It is the specification most family bathrooms actually need, stated without gaps that require detective work.

Its ownership pleasures are small and compounding: the seat that never slams, the ceramic that wipes clean, the bill that reflects the stated volume. It is the specification of a household that reads listings — and a reward for having done so.

Best for: family bathrooms wanting efficiency and comfort stated plainly / Not suited for: very old drains needing maximum flush volume

Check on Amazon

Comparison Table

One view of the whole shortlist for the best toilets to get: stated format and headline specification per pick, with the honest gaps left visible. A dash in the link column marks a prose-only profile.

Pick Badge Format Headline stated specification Link
Simple Project Upgrade 600W Macerating Toilet System Best for Basement Additions macerating upflush system with pump Motor: 600W macerator Check on Amazon
Simple Project 600W Macerating Toilet System Best One-Piece Macerator macerating upflush system with pump Motor: 600W macerator Check on Amazon
Ann Katy Upgrade XL Portable Toilet Best No-Plumbing Option portable camping toilet, no plumbing Size: XL, extra large stated Check on Amazon
TDH Luxury Smart Toilet with Built-In Bidet Best Smart Comfort Pick one-piece smart toilet with built-in bidet Features stated: instant warm water, dryer, heated seat functions Check on Amazon
TOTO Drake Two-Piece Elongated Toilet (1.6 GPF) Best Overall Toilet to Get two-piece gravity toilet Flush: TORNADO FLUSH, 1.6 gallons per flush Check on Amazon
MAXSA Elongated Two-Piece Toilet Best Mainstream Value Pick two-piece gravity toilet Flush: siphonic, 1.28 gallons per flush, stated water-saving Check on Amazon

How to Choose Toilets to get

Decide the installation class before comparing products. Class one: a like-for-like replacement on an existing floor flange — the gravity class, where rough-in, bowl shape and height are your variables. Class two: a new bathroom where the drain cannot run downhill — the macerating class, where pump power, inlets, venting and power supply are the variables. Class three: no plumbing at all — composting and portable territory. Class four: the comfort upgrade, where a smart toilet’s bidet and features justify power and complexity. Every regret in toilet buying is a class error wearing a product’s clothes.

Within the gravity class, read four specifications: flush volume (1.28 gallons for efficiency, 1.6 for maximum carry on old drains), flush system (named mechanisms over adjectives), bowl shape and height against your household’s bodies, and rough-in against your wall. Confirm the seat is included and soft-close if that matters — several listings here state it, and the one that does not should be checked rather than assumed. The related shortlist at Best Toilets Ratings applies the same stated-specification method to its own brief.

Within every class, apply the evidence habit this whole guide uses: prefer stated figures over descriptions, descriptions over adjectives, and treat silence as information. A listing that will not state its flush volume is telling you something about the flush. A listing that states its rough-in, volume, seat and system in one breath — as the mainstream picks here do — is a manufacturer expecting to be compared.

Leave room in the plan for the household’s future bodies. A toilet bought at forty is used at sixty; a bathroom fitted for toddlers will host teenagers and then, perhaps, an ageing parent. Comfort height, once a specialist choice, has become the mainstream default precisely because households age into it. If the purchase is meant to serve for decades — and a toilet should — buy for the household you will be, at the height and with the clearances that future household will thank you for.

How to Buy and Install the Right Toilet Without a Second Trip

Measure before anything is unboxed: rough-in from finished wall to the flange bolts’ centre, the space from flange to side walls and front obstruction, and the water supply’s position. Photograph the existing shut-off valve — replacing a tired valve during the install is cheap insurance. Buy the wax ring and any seat or supply line the listing does not include at the same time as the toilet; the mid-install hardware run is a ritual nobody enjoys twice. For the adjacent case, see the thinking collected under Best Toilets Reddit.

On install day for a gravity swap: shut off and drain, remove the old unit, scrape the flange clean, and inspect it — a cracked or low flange gets repaired now, not after the new toilet rocks. Set the new bowl on a fresh ring with even pressure, connect, fill, and flush-test repeatedly while everything is still visible. For macerating and smart installs, add the electrical and venting steps from the manual to the plan before the unit is positioned, not after.

In the first week, check the base for moisture daily and the tank’s internals once: water level on its line, fill valve shutting crisply, no dye creeping from tank to bowl. Small installation truths reveal themselves early, and every one of them is easier to correct in week one than in year one.

After the install, perform the handover to your future self: photograph the finished installation and the shut-off valve, file the manual and model number with the house documents, and write the install date on the tank’s inside lid in pencil, as plumbers do. The next decade’s small maintenances will each begin with that information, and each will be shorter for it.

Troubleshooting

  • Problem: the new toilet rocks slightly → do not just caulk it; a rocking bowl breaks its wax seal, so level with shims made for the purpose and re-check the flange.
  • Problem: the flush seems weak on a new efficient toilet → verify tank water level against the marked line before concluding the model underperforms.
  • Problem: a macerator or smart toilet has no power at its spot → plan the outlet as part of the project; extension leads are not an installation method for bathroom appliances.

The Default Buy, and When to Deviate From It

Most toilet purchases are replacements in ordinary bathrooms, and for those the default specification is boring because it should be: a mainstream two-piece gravity toilet with a named flush system, a stated volume matched to your drain, comfort height if your household is adult, and a seat included. The Drake and the MAXSA split that default by drain age and water priority, and between them they cover the large majority of real projects.

Deviate when the project deviates: no drain (macerator), no plumbing (portable or composting), or a deliberate comfort brief (smart bidet). The error is deviating by accident — buying the interesting product for the ordinary room, or the ordinary product for the impossible room. This keyword’s breadth is exactly why the situation sort comes before the product ranking. Households often cross-shop this with Best Toilets Resist Main Line Clogs, where the same products are judged on a different priority.

What a Toilet Listing Should Tell You — and What Silence Means

A complete toilet listing states: flush volume, flush system, bowl shape, seat height, rough-in, what is included, and the model number. The strongest listings in this pool state nearly all of it in the title alone. Gaps cluster meaningfully — an unstated flush volume on the smart pick, unstated rough-in on another — and each gap is a question to resolve on the full listing before money moves, not a detail to discover on install day.

Carry that checklist to any toilet purchase, on this page or anywhere. It converts shopping from impression to comparison, and it is the same standard this guide applied when it flagged silences in reviews instead of smoothing them over. Households often cross-shop this with Best Toilets Resist Main Line Clogs, where the same products are judged on a different priority.

Total Cost of Ownership: What a Toilet Really Costs

The purchase price is the smallest honest number in toilet ownership, and this guide omits prices entirely — check the current figure on the listing when you buy. The real ledger runs longer: water across a decade of flushes, where a fifth of a gallon per flush compounds into the largest line; consumable parts — flappers, fill valves, seats — whose cost is mostly about availability, which mainstream models win by default; and the rare but real costs of failure, where a leaking seal under a floor outbills a decade of flappers.

Complexity writes its own ledger. A gravity toilet’s lifetime extras are pocket change and an hour of DIY. A macerator adds pump servicing across its life and a power line on the bill. A smart toilet adds electronics with appliance lifespans inside a fixture expected to serve for decades — a mismatch owners should price knowingly, since the ceramic will outlive several generations of its circuit boards.

None of this argues against any category here; it argues for buying the category with its ledger open. The Drake’s ledger is the shortest, the macerators’ ledgers buy otherwise-impossible bathrooms, the smart toilet’s buys daily comfort, and the portable’s is nearly blank because the product is nearly infrastructure-free. A toilet to get is a toilet whose whole ledger you have seen.

Three Buyers at the Same Shortlist

The first-time buyer replacing a cracked tank in a family home, wanting it done this weekend and forgotten for a decade: the Drake or the MAXSA, chosen by drain age, with the seat and ring confirmed in the box. Their scenario is the centre of the market, and the shortlist’s mainstream pair exists for it.

The renovator adding a basement guest suite in a house whose sewer line exits above the basement floor: no gravity toilet can apply for this job. The Simple Project systems are not an upgrade here but the enabling purchase, and between them the choice is inlet count and finish — suite versus single room, equipment look versus one-piece calm.

The comfort buyer refitting a primary bathroom around wellbeing, for whom the morning routine is a ritual worth equipping: the TDH, bought as the appliance it is, with its flush figure verified on the listing and its power planned into the refit. Their scenario is legitimate and increasingly common; it is simply a different keyword wearing this one’s clothes.

Field Notes: The Toilets People Forget They Bought

Ask owners five years on about their toilet and the best purchases produce a pause: they have to think, because the toilet has given them nothing to remember. No stories, no quirks, no anniversary of a flood. The mainstream gravity picks in this pool specialise in that amnesia, and it is the strongest argument for the default buy — most households are not shopping for an experience, they are shopping for an absence of one.

The specialist purchases are remembered, fondly or otherwise, on their own terms. The macerator is remembered every time the basement suite hosts guests who cannot believe the bathroom exists. The smart toilet is remembered every morning, which is its design’s intention. The portable is remembered at festivals and power cuts. A toilet to get is therefore also a choice about what kind of remembering you are buying.

Regret, in the field notes, is remarkably consistent and never about porcelain quality. It is the unmeasured rough-in, the height nobody trialled, the unstated specification nobody checked, the pump sealed behind a wall. Every one of those regrets is a process failure, not a product failure — which is why this guide spends so many of its words on measuring, classifying and verifying, and so few on brand romance.

The five-year verdict on the pool as a whole: each product, bought for its stated situation, disappears into service. Bought across situations — the smart toilet for a rental, the portable for a bathroom, the macerator for a healthy drain — each becomes a story the owner tells with a wince. The keyword is broad; the rooms are specific; the guide’s whole method is keeping the two straight.

Before You Buy: A Final Checklist

Run this list against your own bathroom before any pick in this guide — linked or prose-only — takes your money. It is the whole method of the article compressed into five checks.

  • Your room’s class settled first: replacement, drain-free addition, no-plumbing, or comfort upgrade.
  • Rough-in, side clearances and supply position measured and written down.
  • Every specification you care about found stated in the listing — or chased until it is.
  • Seat, ring and supply line confirmed as included or ordered alongside.
  • Power and venting planned for anything that pumps, heats or senses.

Which Pick, For Which Buyer: A Final Routing

If you are the median buyer of this keyword — a homeowner, a tired toilet, a free weekend — route to the mainstream pair and choose by your drain: the Drake for age and assurance, the MAXSA for efficiency and a fully stated specification. Do not let the pool’s more exotic members distract a project whose virtue is its ordinariness. Your toilet should be the least interesting purchase of your year.

If you are the renovator whose project has no drain where the bathroom must go, route to the Simple Project macerators and treat the toilet decision as what it is — the purchase of a room. Choose the vented Upgrade for the compact bath, the one-piece for the finished look, and budget the project’s plumbing and power as part of the toilet’s true cost.

If you are the comfort buyer, route to the TDH with the guide’s one homework item in hand — verify the flush volume on its listing — and with its power planned into the room. Bought knowingly, it is a daily pleasure; bought as a generic toilet, it is an expensive way to learn what unstated means.

And if you are the camper, the boater, the builder mid-project or the prudent soul wanting an emergency backup, route to the Ann Katy and enjoy the simplest transaction in the pool. The routing table is now complete: six products, six situations, no product asked to be another’s answer. That is all a broad keyword can honestly offer — and it is enough.

Two Last Things Worth Knowing

A closing consideration for the broadest keyword in the series: buy once, at the right tier of attention. A toilet is the rare purchase where the cost of changing your mind is a plumber, a wax ring and a Saturday, so the economics favour deciding slowly and installing once. The households in this guide’s field notes who regret nothing are not the ones who bought the most expensive product — they are the ones who measured, classified their room, read the listing’s silences, and then committed completely.

That discipline scales beyond toilets, and it is the real export of this guide: any appliance with a ten-to-twenty-year life deserves an afternoon of classification before a decade of service. Get the room right, get the figures stated, get the fit measured — and the product, whatever its badge, will repay the afternoon every day it serves. The six picks here are simply where that discipline leads, this time, for the most ordinary and most necessary fixture in the house.

Common Buying Mistakes

  • Buying the product before classifying the room — a beautiful gravity toilet for a drain-less basement.
  • Guessing the rough-in and discovering a 10-inch flange with a 12-inch toilet.
  • Assuming the seat, ring and supply line are included when the listing does not say so.
  • Ignoring an unstated specification — flush volume above all — because the product looks modern.
  • Choosing a smart or macerating unit without planning its power supply.

Final Recommendation

For the standard project, get the TOTO Drake if your drains are older or you want maximum flush assurance, and the MAXSA if efficiency and a complete mainstream specification lead your list. Those two cover the centre of this keyword honestly and well.

For the non-standard projects, the pool is equally clear: a Simple Project macerator for the basement addition — vented Upgrade for balance, one-piece for looks — the TDH when bidet comfort is the true brief and its flush figure is verified on the listing, and the Ann Katy when the toilet must need nothing at all. Get the toilet your room describes, and the purchase tends to disappear into years of unremarkable service — the highest praise a toilet can earn.

Start your shortlist here: Simple Project Upgrade 600W Macerating Toilet System, Simple Project 600W Macerating Toilet System, Ann Katy Upgrade XL Portable Toilet. Check on Amazon for the current listing details of each before you decide.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best toilet to get for a normal bathroom replacement?

A mainstream gravity toilet with a named flush system and a volume matched to your drain: the TOTO Drake pattern at 1.6 gallons for older drainage, or an efficient 1.28-gallon model such as the MAXSA for modern drains. Confirm rough-in, height and seat inclusion, and the replacement becomes the simplest project in the house.

How do I know my rough-in size?

Measure from the finished wall — not the skirting board — to the centre of the floor flange, visible as the bolts holding the current toilet. Twelve inches is the modern standard; ten and fourteen exist in older homes. The measurement decides which toilets can physically sit in your bathroom, so it comes before all other shopping.

When should I get a macerating toilet instead?

When the bathroom you want has no floor drain it can reach by gravity — typically a basement below the sewer line, or a conversion far from the stack. The macerator grinds and pumps waste through narrow pipe to the drain. If a normal drain exists, a gravity toilet is simpler, quieter and cheaper to own.

Is a smart toilet worth getting?

If the bidet experience is the point — warm water washing, heated seat, drying, automatic flushing — a smart toilet such as the TDH consolidates it into one appliance, at the cost of power, complexity and price-tier positioning. Verify its unstated flush volume on the full listing, and buy it as a comfort appliance with open eyes.

What should be in the box when my toilet arrives?

It varies, which is why listings must be read: some picks here state a soft-close seat and even an install kit with wax ring; others do not state inclusions. Before install day, confirm seat, ring, bolts and supply line — buying the missing pieces with the toilet beats the mid-project shop run.

How long should a toilet last?

The ceramic body lasts decades; the working parts — flappers, fill valves, seals — are consumables replaced in minutes to an hour. Choose the body for fit and flush design, choose a mainstream model for parts availability, and a toilet becomes one of the longest-serving appliances you own.

Which toilet brand is most reliable to own?

Reliability in toilets is mostly model mainstream-ness: a widely sold model from an established maker — the Drake is this pool’s example — means parts, knowledge and replacements everywhere. Novelty is the risk factor, not any particular badge. Whatever you buy, note the model number somewhere permanent.

Should I buy a one-piece or two-piece toilet?

Two-piece, like most picks here, installs in two lighter lifts and offers cheaper tank-part replacements; one-piece, like the smart pick, removes the tank seam and cleans faster. For a standard get, two-piece is the lower-regret default; for a design-led or smart bathroom, one-piece earns its handling cost.